Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Posted under General

It's that time again. For all of these, I'm not sure what hte quality issues are, if any; in many cases, especially compared to the artist's other output.

SFW
post #9581125
post #9581812
post #9581923 (one person said "Hands"; what exactly is wrong with the hands? especially compared to the expectations of the art style used)

QUESTIONABLE
post #9538750 (maybe this should have impossible_clothes?)
post #9576339
post #9615313
post #9625753 Thanks!

Thanks again!

Updated by andlabs

andlabs said:

It's that time again. For all of these, I'm not sure what hte quality issues are, if any; in many cases, especially compared to the artist's other output.

SFW
post #9581125
post #9581812
post #9581923 (one person said "Hands"; what exactly is wrong with the hands? especially compared to the expectations of the art style used)

post #9581125 : I think the problem is its style. Yeah, there is others works of this artist approved, but these was uploaded by a contributor, and they can skip voting pool.
post #9581812 : For me, looks like a sketch, and I agree this is consistent with artist's style, so I think your post was just overlooked twice.

post #9581923 : The last fingers are too much small, the looks like distorted and she has a congenital problem with her hands.

distribooter said:

post #9769702
post #9779383
post #9779397

could anyone shed some light on how these are worse than any of the same artist's currently active posts? I specifically uploaded these because I saw the artist already had multiple approved posts in the same style so there's nothing i can really infer from seeing these getting rejected.
any feedback is appreciated

It was overlooked, because those works are amazing! If you can, wait some time and try to appeal, maybe somene could approve.

@Unbreakable @RaisingK @Strobe_Red @evazion
Speaking as someone who's a Contributor on another booru may I ask why my uploads from the last three years seem to be subject to a slot machine chance approval level? Every other booru's admins and mods approve a post when the approvers pass on approving a post that doesn't break any rules or is of acceptable quality. I go above and beyond tagging my posts, I make a new artist page if there isn't one, I update tags with the Pixiv information if there is one, I site my sources when I can, & I translate the images and commentary when I can/remember. I've been uploading a variety of images to figure out what works and it's always random. I've tried uploading something from an artist that has a 100% approval rating (wasn't approved) and numerous pictures that don't exist anywhere except on danbooru where I've posted them (which have been unapproved), so preservation isn't a factor. I've seen what some of the Contributor's have uploaded here (I won't name them, I'm not here to fight) so I know I haven't uploaded anything of lower quality/off topic than them (watermarks, sketches, western furry art, etc.). If someone like me who does everything right when uploading something is subjected to seemingly randomized approval, what chance does anyone else have? I know it's not that approvers have missed my uploads due to a large amount of uploads since it always says at least 8 approvers have viewed my uploads. If I'm the asshole here then fine I guess I'll just keep sparsely uploading. I'm just trying to figure out what happened to this place.

Jyuu said:

I don't know if can help you, but I found this thread topic #24186 talking about your question.

OP makes a great point. 2 of my 3 deletions (post #8414485 and post #9649087 (NSFW)) are both from artists who have everything that was posted approved and active for years besides their earlier works. The 1st one is especially egregious since quality wise it's the exact same as the parent and all of their other works, but the approvers just didn't feel like approving that one that week

I have quite a few Uploads unposted since I'm trying to keep my Deletion % low, and with the time of year, I'm trying not to post unless I'm 100% confident it'll be approved.

It's just the life of being a blue name lol

B17Bomber said:

OP makes a great point. 2 of my 3 deletions (post #8414485 and post #9649087 (NSFW)) are both from artists who have everything that was posted approved and active for years besides their earlier works. The 1st one is especially egregious since quality wise it's the exact same as the parent and all of their other works, but the approvers just didn't feel like approving that one that week

I have quite a few Uploads unposted since I'm trying to keep my Deletion % low, and with the time of year, I'm trying not to post unless I'm 100% confident it'll be approved.

It's just the life of being a blue name lol

Became worse, in August has a fewer number of approver, some of my posts were reviewed for only 7 or 8 approvers.

Can someone explain to me about why post #9832631 didn’t get approved. I had uploaded it before another contributor uploaded the parent post #9833821 which looked nearly the same as the original post (the only difference I can notice is the character in the parent post reveal her cleavage). Also, approvers can flagged the approved posts if they see them don’t deserve so If the original post didn’t get approved then why the parent post can, even almost all other post from this artist got approved. I hope someone can take another look and give it another chance.

Updated by Legendliner