Loli/shota check thread.

sgcdonmai said:
I'll disagree with Hazuki on this one - I think it should be tagged. All that can be seen seems to lack indicators of adulthood.

The girl's "onii-chan" comments, and mention of doing the same stuff in school, do not indicate any particular age range, except that they're clearly not in college. The image has a bad Pixiv ID and doesn't show up on okina sen's gallery there, plus his FC2 blog seems to be missing, so there's no way I can confirm any loli via tags or comments. Best leave it off for now.

Uhh, what? It's way more explicit, and just as lacking in "any indicators of adulthood". What the artist writes or not is insubstantial if it looks loli.

葉月 said:
Uhh, what? It's way more explicit, and just as lacking in "any indicators of adulthood".

Explicit, yes, but I'd argue those breasts might be construable as non-loli. Thing is, that viewing angle (and what appears to be some foreshortening) makes it difficult to accurately discern her proportions, so I can't really factor in the rest of her figure.

What the artist writes or not is insubstantial if it looks loli.

Agreed, but contingent on that "if".

I only consider artist's commentary, tags, etc., as evidence when it's not clearly observable whether the image deserves the tag or not.

sgcdonmai said:
Explicit, yes, but I'd argue those breasts might be construable as non-loli.

Might be, but the face is very much childish. I say it's much more in the loli land than the (overall almost innocent) post #854138.

post #482412 - Not shota?

葉月 said:
Might be, but the face is very much childish. I say it's much more in the loli land than the (overall almost innocent) post #854138.

Could post #640314 stand as a counterpoint?

T5J8F8 said:
post #482412 - Not shota?

Could post #640314 stand as a counterpoint?

I'm not sure, Satori looks pretty loli in this one. And the fact the circle is lolita_channel is not exactly yielding evidence to the contrary.

Koishi looks oddly older overall than Satori in that one.

T5J8F8 said:
post #482412 - Not shota?

Nothing I saw there made me think "shota" in the slightest, so, removed.

sgcdonmai said:
Koishi looks oddly older overall than Satori in that one.

Satori's broken and shortened spine makes her smaller (and therefore appear younger) whereas the squeezed breasts between Koishi's dislocated arms (shoulder) are a sign of maturity.

post #857579

T5J8F8 said:
post #857579

Loli.

post #331145 - Pretty sure "not loli".

post #805497

Cyberia-Mix said:
post #805497

Somewhat mixed signals, but I think it's more loli than not.

Agreed. The only thing that threw me was the fact that the thighs are longer than the spine in that one.

post #672640

Not loli, well defined waist and descent sized breasts.

Well I tend to think it's totally counterbalanced by the size of her head, but fine.

Not with a bust→waist→hip deviation like that.

post #863956

I don't know the characters too well but it looks like flat chest to me but never hurt to be sure

IMHO, it looks loli enough there.

post #807704

I feel dumb for asking when it looks obvious like here but I get confused when the tagging looks wrong even after multiple well informed taggers have seen the post.