Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Hiramaru said:

I'm not even gonna ask why the ones I uploaded were of poor quality, or not approved, because from what I could gather, even quality comics, fanart and whatnot above me WERE still disapproved or still on appeal.

Like, holy cow, what's wrong with some of it? What's the criteria? Just "because"?

You have to also consider the amount of posts they have to go through vs. the amount of posts uploaded, and that all approvers have lives to attend to. Plus, a number of times, posts that would be approved fall through the cracks.

Also:
post #10098907 : Consistent with other tank arts by the artist.~~
post #10109830 : Part of a variant set, focusing on Kinich's body rather than his gear.

Could I please get some feedback on these unapproved posts?

post #10011598 and post #10004714 were unapproved
but match the quality, style, + crossover of post #10053158 and post #10053122

i guess i will ask again, why? post #10093046

post #10109839
post #10091677
post #10088754
post #10088451
post #10088445
post #10066762

Would like to know what's wrong with these posts? All of them are nicely drawn, especially the Pulchra posts

I was wondering if i could get some feedback on these posts
as far as i can tell they're decent enough.
post #10110849
post #10110810
post #10110784
post #10110797

More failed appeals

GENERAL
post #9913180 (weird hat, but everything else is fine?) Thanks!
post #9915525 (somewhat simplistic chibi style, but no worse quality than the artist's other posts?) Thanks!

QUESTIONABLE
post #9917956
post #9940552
post #9940560

EXPLICIT
post #9915662
post #9953704 (weird bar censor design, but everything else is fine?)

Thanks again!

post #10103894
post #10104365
post #10105108
post #10110529

post #10108208
post #10090580
post #10113097
post #10095540
post #10107512
post #10111967
post #10107199
post #10104910
post #10099423
post #10090580
post #10107455
post #10076007

post #10107267
post #10107269

Was there anything wrong with these posts? All of these artists other approved posts are the same style and quality

Anything wrong with post #10114546? Looks decent in my opinion!

Anybody please tell me why these two are gathering so much disapproval and disinterest?

post #10089590 Quality good and consistent with other artwork by the same artist.
post #10102741 Quality consistent with other approved artwork in the same pool.

post #7257046 ←I uploaded it a long time ago, but this artist is the only one who has not been approved for the five posts I uploaded.

post #10100080
post #10000534 ←No text difference
post #9997632 ←High quality, the artist's work also has a high pass rate
post #9890590
post #9006088

They are not of such low quality, they have been there for a long time

melon00 said:

post #10109110
And another one with only 9 approvers
Once again a great art, why the disinterest? I would really like to know please.

post #10117356
And another one with 8 approvers
Great art, am i really that unlucky?

post #10094858
post #10098045
i dont know what the issue was as these both have nice quality

why did post #10099520 not make it through appeals when post #10054923 is active

AngelFlash said:

why did post #10099520 not make it through appeals when post #10054923 is active

The latter was uploaded by a contributor and didn't go through the approval queue.

jxh2154 said:

People have been asking for a thread where feedback on uploads could be obtained. So here it is. I have some reservations about how acrimonious this thread is likely to get, and if it turns into nothing more than a flame-fest, I will lock it.

Rules for those requesting feedback:
#1 - You are not guaranteed feedback. It is entirely voluntary to give it.
#2 - Danbooru may simply not be an appropriate place for your favorite art. If so, accept this and move on.
#3 - Try not to be too thin-skinned,and don't take things personally.

Rules for those giving feedback:
#1 - Give constructive feedback only.
#2 - Refrain from name-calling. Asking people to be thick-skinned doesn't mean you're allowed to be insulting.

Hi. I'm new here and want to become a contributor, but I don't know if there is a limit of comments or posts I need to do so. Can anyone help?

thisisfukinstupid777 said:

Hi. I'm new here and want to become a contributor, but I don't know if there is a limit of comments or posts I need to do so. Can anyone help?

This isn't the right thread for this, but I will quote from the mod queue wiki.

Contributor-level users have their posts automatically approved, bypassing the modqueue. You may be granted this privilege by consistently uploading high-quality posts while maintaining a low deletion ratio. The general criteria for Contributor level is having 500-750 uploads and having a recent deletion ratio of around 5% or lower, though users with very few deleted posts might be promoted at lower thresholds.

post #10115236
post #10118645
post #10118649
post #10118655
post #10118669

post #10109083 got deleted despite post #10109089 and post #10109094 making the cut.

post #10119426