post #8227072
Official art
Posted under General
post #8227072
Official art
unsure why this was rejected
post #8232362 post #8232363 post #8232364 post #8232365I got a 4 deletion streak for a 1up and variants of post #8043736. Can't afford to lose 12 slots for 3 days if the appeals fail, so want some feedback first if I should appeal them or why they weren't good (unless it's only no interest by anyone who checked rather than post issues). 12 approvers looked at it which is why I'd rather ask for feedback first instead of going straight to an appeal. Reflagged. I'm done with this set.
post #8219466
This is the unfinished (and uploaded first) of post #8227367; only the finished one got accepted and this one's appeal is about to fail. I've uploaded accepted sketches from Samlatte before (post #8083187, post #8119524). Why not this one? Too sketchy?
Updated by WRS
Changli said:
post #8232362 post #8232363 post #8232364 post #8232365
I got a 4 deletion streak for a 1up and variants of post #8043736. Can't afford to lose 12 slots for 3 days if the appeals fail, so want some feedback first if I should appeal them or why they weren't good (unless it's only no interest by anyone who checked rather than post issues). 12 approvers looked at it which is why I'd rather ask for feedback first instead of going straight to an appeal imo at least.
post #8232362 post #8232363 post #8232364 post #8232365: The eyes' position on the faces is odd and amateurishly drawn. The face looks like it was compressed into one single 2D plane, it has no depth. Here are some examples of looking back posts that do this head pose better: post #8244881, post #8240543 and post #8240308. The face needs to have a more complex outline when drawn from this angle. I wouldn't appeal this personally, but seeing that one of the variations got approved, you could try, but the one approved is more likely to be flagged than the other variations of it getting approved.
post #8219466
This is the unfinished (and uploaded first) of post #8227367; only the finished one got accepted and this one's appeal is about to fail. I've uploaded accepted sketches from Samlatte before (post #8083187, post #8119524). Why not this one? Too sketchy?
post #8219466: It has some chance of getting approved, but the unshaded WIP still looks inferior to the final approved version. I would suggest not uploading WIPs at all unless they're of good enough quality on their own.
Updated by user 1211591
I take your level of feedback very cautiously given that you've had a track record of giving wrong or bad feedback numerous times and have been talked to about how you convey feedback (if at all) as a non-Approver in this thread. Obviously an unfinished work is going to be inferior to a finished work.
post #5652815
The same as the rest of Kurotama's catalogue. Blowjob-face in black and white. Not sure why this one was rejected twice.
yooyooko said:
post #8232362 post #8232363 post #8232364 post #8232365: The eyes' position on the faces is odd and amateurishly drawn. The face looks like it was compressed into one single 2D plane, it has no depth. Here are some examples of looking back posts that do this head pose better: post #8244881, post #8240543 and post #8240308. The face needs to have a more complex outline when drawn from this angle. I wouldn't appeal this personally, but seeing that one of the variations got approved, you could try, but the one approved is more likely to be flagged than the other variations of it getting approved.
post #8219466: It has some chance of getting approved, but the unshaded WIP still looks inferior to the final approved version. I would suggest not uploading WIPs at all unless they're of good enough quality on their own.
@yooyooko this kind of advice should only be given by approvers, please stop doing this.
can someone tell me why these post weren't approved?
post #8218883
post #8218829
post #8219144
i can maybe see the 3rd one since it's not as detailed as the other 2, but it's supossed to look like a manga panel. are manga-styled drawings usually deleted here?
Updated by Leonyx
Hi, any feedback on why this post wasn't approved? Please give a second chance.
post #6500782
Updated by SidBarrett
Could someone give me help to understand why this post was rejected?
Hello, could I get some info on what was wrong with this art?
Why was my post rejected? This is a child of the most upvoted sound_voltex post and this artist only has 1 other deletion out of 375 posts...
Any idea why post #8223683 got rejected? Not sure what could be wrong with it.
Thanks for the help!
Updated by alphashitlord
Normally I can come up with a theory about what's lacking, but this one stumped me as it seems good quality and well-detailed. Is there something I'm missing?
Hi, Would appreciate some feedback on what's wrong with the post #8239735
I've just started out with making some simple video edits/fan animations of art that I have found online and noticed that none of the 6 posts that I have put up have been approved. I found this kind of odd as I had gotten a minimum of 10 or more likes or favorites for every single one and just wanted to know the reason why they weren't getting the green light.