Posted under General
post #8172527
post #8172551
post #8172563
I normally wouldn't consider appealing these, particularly since they already went through the appeal process for not getting enough looks the first time, but they are part of a sequence where the first two posts were approved and they don't seem noticeably lower quality than the first two to my eye. Is it worth a second appeal on those grounds, or is that just a waste of everyone's time?
Anyone got a clue why post #8199587 wasn't approved?
Can someone explain why my image was deleted? I don't see anything wrong with the quality.
Hi, any idea why these were deleted?
post #8148111
post #8156850
post #8162769
post #8162961
Especially asking about the first two, the first one is a non-censored version of the parent post which was already approved, and the second one is an artist who was specifically requested in the upload bounty thread.
Thanks!
Why was post #8189526 deleted?
I don't understand. It even has 59 score and 57 favorites. So despite that, just because some 5 random approvers didn't like it, it gets deleted? What puts their opinion above those 59 people who liked it?
WaifuMaster9000 said:
Why was post #8189526 deleted?
I don't understand. It even has 59 score and 57 favorites. So despite that, just because some 5 random approvers didn't like it, it gets deleted? What puts their opinion above those 59 people who liked it?
Pretty much that voting users don't care about quality when upvoting. Over 100 people can upvote the ugliest image, it doesn't make the image better.
Anyway, i like the image, but I dislike the animation.
Hi, any feedback on why this post wasn't approved? Please give it a second chance.
post #6337776
Updated by SidBarrett
The bulk update request #31820 (forum #308944) has been rejected by @Changli.
WaifuMaster9000 said:
Why was post #8189526 deleted?
I don't understand. It even has 59 score and 57 favorites. So despite that, just because some 5 random approvers didn't like it, it gets deleted? What puts their opinion above those 59 people who liked it?
The process has flaws but it's what has worked for the board for this long. Their opinion is 'above' because they have proven themselves to be worthy of being an approver. The board absolutely needs quality control of some kind and this is the process. Yeah it can be frustrating but it's part of uploading to Danbooru which no one is forced to do. Also there are very obvious reasons why score has never played into approval of images. A non-small portion of the userbase is incredibly skewed towards particular tastes and while that's fine, it shouldn't be and isn't a deciding factor in what gets approved.
This is why the appeal system exists. So that non-approvers can have a chance at some input. I've noticed some people in this thread seem almost averse to appealing but still upset at their lack of agency. I get it takes upload slots but if you believe in an image enough to be truly upset at its deletion, it is an option. You are promised nothing, but it is there.
I hate to bring this up right after you've appealed it, but post #8189526 is a duplicate of post #6473666. I've added the relation and duplicate tag.
vipguy64 said:
I hate to bring this up right after you've appealed it, but post #8189526 is a duplicate of post #6473666. I've added the relation and duplicate tag.
Oop, well. Likely another reason it didn't go through. There are lots of reasons besides 'approvers mean and bad'.
appealed some of my deleted posts, but i really wish i got some feedback on why they were deleted. they seem good quality to me and seems to go with website rules.
post #8134383
post #8134569
post #8194563
post #8194581
post #8194617
post #8201033
Could someone tell me why these got rejected?
Dynastes_king said:
post #8201377
No drawing mistakes
I think most of these could clear, pending appeals. #8198803 should include a mention that it is a .png version of the previous image. #8201377 is fine and should be appealed. #8201430 -- I'll be honest, this one looks a bit wonky. The hips and chest feel a little odd to me. I think it might be fine on appeal, but this is a very borderline case. #8200765 -- this one looks a bit rough in the line work but I think it could pass on appeal.
I find it does help to add a little note why you think it is worth reconsidering. It doesn't need to be long but I do think these message are considered on reevaluation.
