Deprecate holding_legs

Posted under Tags

nonamethanks

In forum #425378 I originally had this, but I removed it because i didn't realize we had holding legs which already is mostly for holding one's own legs:

imply holding_own_ankle -> holding_own_leg
imply holding_own_ankles -> holding_own_legs

alias grabbing_own_legs -> holding_own_legs

But it doesn't seem we have a tag that can express specifically this kind of rating:e post: post #11011957. Basically a character holding both of her legs in place while being folded. There's a lot of it under folded or m legs.
At a minimum, most of this tag should end up creating holding own legs.

The problem is that we also have hugging own legs which is massive in comparison, and also suggests some degree of holding.

Reply
aster1a

nonamethanks said in forum #425498:

But it doesn't seem we have a tag that can express specifically this kind of rating:e post: post #11011957. Basically a character holding both of her legs in place while being folded. There's a lot of it under folded or m legs.
At a minimum, most of this tag should end up creating holding own legs.

That post and other ones I’ve seen in holding legs made me think of a potential spreading own legs tag. And a spreading another's legs counterpart.

The problem with holding own/another's legs is that there’s so many poses one can find by searching them. As evazion said in forum #410358, holding own legs is ambiguous with many tags listed in that reply. Holding legs already overlaps with them.

There’s a scenario where holding own legs and holding another's legs are also deprecated, but I’ll stop here for now. I want to know if the tags for spreading legs make sense.

Reply
nonamethanks

Someone needs to edit holding legs to add a deprecation wiki so that we get full picture of how many legs on hands tags we have and how we need to divide them.

Even after the consolidation in forum #425378 there's still way too many ambiguous tags.

These lists don't even include the other hold tags like knee_hold etc. There's way too many when we should have a handful, a nightmare of a fragmentation.

Reply
aster1a

nonamethanks said in forum #437167:

Someone needs to edit holding legs to add a deprecation wiki so that we get full picture of how many legs on hands tags we have and how we need to divide them.

Even after the consolidation in forum #425378 there's still way too many ambiguous tags.

These lists don't even include the other hold tags like knee_hold etc. There's way too many when we should have a handful, a nightmare of a fragmentation.

Added those tags to the wiki, plus some more I found on the way and I don’t even know if that’s everything. I’m trying to separate them in different sections because it’s a mess. And some probably need to be deprecated.

Aside from that, I renamed knee hold to holding with knees (matching with holding_with_* tags) since the original name sounds ambiguous. Could be holding between knees, but I went with the shorter name.

Edit: Nevermind, I’ll go with holding between knees due to the existence of kneepit hold (holding with a kneepit).

Updated by aster1a

Reply
1