Girls' Frontline character skin implications

Posted under Tags

NNTBot said in forum #424279:

BUR #56443 has been rejected.

create implication springfield_(enjoy_the_fragrance)_(girls'_frontline_2) -> springfield_(girls'_frontline_2)

Eh, I'm conflicted on this. I personally avoided making a tag for this because I viewed it as difficult to properly maintain, for one main reason: this costume is not exclusive to GFL2.

Per post #3208361, Springfield's cafe costume has been a thing since GFL1, and it feels incredibly odd to have a tag for just the GFL2 version of it, whose main differences are the Zucchero Café emblem on the top left of her apron, and the fact that she now wears shorts and thighhighs instead of jeans (which you can't tell in most art anyway because most art is from her thighs upward, hiding them with her apron).

nonamethanks said in forum #424959:

Well, I think the posts pre-GFL2 can get the tag too if it's the same costume, but at that point it should imply Springfield (Girls' Frontline) instead. springfield_(girls'_frontline) -springfield_(girls'_frontline_2) apron has 400 posts. Thoughts about the name?

Well, if we're generalizing it across the game, we can't use the GFL2 skin name by default, in my opinion. I'd rather we go with springfield (cafe) (girls' frontline) in that case. The GFL2 name can be a utility alias.

BUR #58189 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

nuke nemesis_(serene_dark_river)_(girls'_frontline_2)

I'm sorry @zgryphon, but this is a glorified default costume tag for a copyright that doesn't do that. Even if we had default costume tags for GFL2 (which would be nemesis_(galaxy_interpretation)_(girls'_frontline_2) for Nemesis), you could just use that tag and minus out the cloak tag to get the same result of as Serene Dark River.

And also, "A paid skin"?? You can easily fact-check this, it's a free skin you get from doing Beginner Evaluation! The fact you seemed to have not thought this tag through just forces me to propose a nuke for it.

Damian0358 said in forum #434855:

BUR #58189 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

nuke nemesis_(serene_dark_river)_(girls'_frontline_2)

I'm sorry @zgryphon, but this is a glorified default costume tag for a copyright that doesn't do that. Even if we had default costume tags for GFL2 (which would be nemesis_(galaxy_interpretation)_(girls'_frontline_2) for Nemesis), you could just use that tag and minus out the cloak tag to get the same result of as Serene Dark River.

And also, "A paid skin"?? You can easily fact-check this, it's a free skin you get from doing Beginner Evaluation! The fact you seemed to have not thought this tag through just forces me to propose a nuke for it.

The paid skin part I'll hold my hand up to--lapse of concentration--but the rest of it, well... it has a name, that seemed grounds enough to me for it to have a tag as well. But hey, I'm not your priest.

zgryphon said in forum #434864:

The paid skin part I'll hold my hand up to--lapse of concentration--but the rest of it, well... it has a name, that seemed grounds enough to me for it to have a tag as well. But hey, I'm not your priest.

I know the name argument has been used before, in the context of Overwatch skins that are just recolors, forum #277335, but just because something has a name doesn't automatically make it worth of a tag in my eyes. There needs to be a real reason behind it too.

1 10 11 12 13 14 15