[APPROVED] [fate] Everything else

mass update archer_(fate/extra) -> robin_hood_(fate)
mass update lancer_(fate/extra) -> vlad_iii_(fate/extra)
mass update rider_(fate/extra) -> francis_drake_(fate)
mass update berserker_(fate/extra) -> lu_bu_(fate)
mass update assassin_(fate/extra) -> li_shuwen_(fate)
mass update caster_(fate/extra_ccc) -> hans_christian_andersen_(fate)
mass update saber_(fate/extra_ccc_fox_tail) -> suzuka_gozen_(fate)
mass update lancer_(fate/prototype) -> cu_chulainn_(fate/prototype)
mass update rider_(fate/prototype) -> perseus_(fate)
mass update archer_(fate/prototype_fragments) -> arash_(fate)
mass update lancer_(fate/prototype_fragments) -> brynhildr_(fate)
mass update rider_(fate/prototype_fragments) -> ozymandias_(fate)
mass update caster_(fate/prototype_fragments) -> paracelsus_(fate)
mass update assassin_(fate/prototype_fragments) -> hassan_of_serenity_(fate)
mass update berserker_(fate/prototype_fragments) -> jekyll_and_hyde_(fate)
mass update saber_of_black -> siegfried_(fate)
mass update archer_of_black -> chiron_(fate)
mass update lancer_of_black -> vlad_iii_(fate/apocrypha)
mass update caster_of_black -> avicebron_(fate)
mass update berserker_of_black -> frankenstein's_monster_(fate)
mass update archer_of_red -> atalanta_(fate)
mass update rider_of_red -> achilles_(fate)
mass update caster_of_red -> william_shakespeare_(fate)
mass update assassin_of_red -> semiramis_(fate)
mass update berserker_of_red -> spartacus_(fate)
mass update kotomine_shirou -> amakusa_shirou_(fate)
mass update demon_archer -> oda_nobunaga_(fate)

Link to request

These are cleaning up the remaining Fate character tags, based on ckretaznman's list from the main thread. In general I prefer using the _(fate) qualifier unless there's a reason to use a more specific one to help disambiguate. These are all simple updates since they are generally too small to make aliases worthwhile. If there are any missing cosplay or related tags plpease let me know. If there are any characters not covered in this list also let me know.

There are three more that are contentious:

mass update archer_(fate/prototype) -> gilgamesh_(fate/prototype)
mass update saber_(fate/prototype) -> arthur_pendragon_(fate)
mass update saber lion -> artoria_pendragon_lion_(fate)

I'm not sure if Fate/prototype's Gilgamesh is distinct enough to require it's own tag. The other two fall into the gray area of the Pendragon characters that we probably want to hold off on for now.

EDIT: The bulk update request #1427 (forum #140792) has been approved by @albert.

I guess this thread can be used to further continue the discussion of other characters that may or may not need new tags.

What is everyone's opinion of toosaka_rin being separated from ereshkigal_(fate/grand_order) and ishtar_(fate/grand_order)?

mj1234 said:

What is everyone's opinion of toosaka_rin being separated from ereshkigal_(fate/grand_order) and ishtar_(fate/grand_order)?

I definitely think they should be separated.

+1 on this request, and

EB said:

I definitely think they should be separated.

+1 on this. Nothing's ever gonna get done otherwise.

remove implication ereshkigal_(fate/grand_order) -> toosaka_rin
remove implication ishtar_(fate/grand_order) -> toosaka_rin

Link to request

Also agreeing with the removal.

EDIT: The bulk update request #1429 (forum #140869) has been approved by @albert.

Just because those two use Rin as their vessel doesn't mean they are Rin. +1 to unimplicating them.

Unimplicate, but don't make a catchall tag.

willsolvit said:

Unimplicate, but don't make a catchall tag.

I also strongly disagree with these *_(all) tags, so you won't see a request from me^^.

I also believe a catchall/umbrella tag is unnecessary for Ereshkigal and Ishtar

Technically, Ishtar has two forms, her base Archer form and the Summer Rider form. But that is another can of worms.

WatcherCCG said:

Technically, Ishtar has two forms, her base Archer form and the Summer Rider form. But that is another can of worms.

Two forms that are looking physically absolute identical. But yeah, you're right.

The bulk update request #1429 (forum #140869) has been approved by @albert.

The bulk update request #1427 (forum #140792) has been approved by @albert.

I'll clean up the two tags to remove Rin's chartag when applicable.

Edit: Done.
I edited the tag out of most of the pictures, but I left it in those where it was immediate that Rin was being referenced (some comic pages with Emiya Alter and Parvati in particular, for obvious reasons).

Wow that was quick, I'll try to do some of these once a day after I'm done with work and some other projects.

saber_lily
artoria_pendragon_(swimsuit_rider_alter)
artoria_pendragon_(swimsuit_archer)
jeanne_d'arc_(alter)_(fate)

I looked up the other Sabers and they appear to be clean (I could be wrong) so I'll go through them again later. I'm not sure if dark_sakura, parvati_(fate/grand_order) and sakura is supposed to be one entity with three implicated tags, so I ignored it (imo they should be separated).

I cleaned up the Neros yesterday and Saber Alter when we split it from Saber so those should be good.

I cleaned up jeanne_d'arc_(alter)_(fate). I'll go through her normal tag to find missing tags tomorrow.

Thanks.

Hya, can we remove every implication/alias for assassin_(fate/prototype_fragments)_(cosplay)?

Trying to remove it.

keonas said:

Hya, can we remove every implication/alias for assassin_(fate/prototype_fragments)_(cosplay)?

Trying to remove it.

The cosplay implications are created automatically. You have to move both the cosplay tag and the chartag from every picture.