Posted under Tags
There could be some argument against it but looking through the lense of someone who's just blacklisting vore, I don't think they want to see any of this if they add it to their blacklist; either way I also think that when searching vore, how exactly they're being vored is not too important.
Kawakijin said in forum #448477:
There could be some argument against it but looking through the lense of someone who's just blacklisting vore, I don't think they want to see any of this if they add it to their blacklist; either way I also think that when searching vore, how exactly they're being vored is not too important.
I would argue the audience of vore and cock vore are not that similar.
Feels like it should be kept together just for ease of blacklisting. If I was the average browser and added vore to my blacklist and I still saw post #11594465 I would be pretty pissed.
Related: unbirthing which is basically vaginal vore.
Also related: animal insertion
The problem with a lot of our vore tags is that it's one of those fetishes that is regarded as really weird, so no one outside their niche audience really wants to see that. There's also the problem that vore has multiple subsets that are not going to be appealing to everyone in that specific niche. I'm not crazy about cock vore at all, despite enjoying regular old vore.
Chances are good the average vore enjoying will probably blacklist the tags that they do not like. No, my main problem is that there's someone getting eaten...And then there's vore. It's hard to describe if you aren't into it, but it's kinda a "you know it when you see it" kink I feel. There's no reason for post #10525139 to be lumped together with post #11576953. The former is a goofy light-hearted post that is clearly not based in kink and just the artist poking fun at Oguri Cap for being a glutton. The latter is very much a kink sort of thing that is being sexualized and is absolutely what I expect and want to see in a vore tag.
Unfortunately, as we only have the vore tag, you're kinda screwed on both ends. The blacklisters miss out on cute and funny posts that they might enjoy because they hit the blacklist. While the people who actually want vore are kinda stuck wading through said posts. I know I sure don't want post #6692958 in the vore tag.
As a result, it's impossible to deal with the subsets that are all much more clearly kink because otherwise they will be lumped together with vore rating:general for as long as we don't have a non-sexual "someone getting eaten" tag.
I don't think "people don't like this" is an argument to put together completely different things just because semantically they sound similar. cock vore is for someone getting vacuumed up by a dick, vore is for someone being eaten alive. They're completely different posts. If they didn't both have "vore" in the name you wouldn't want these to be together.
They're named similarly because they're related. If we wanted to be pedantic over it, vore would be named oral vore and they'd all imply a vore base tag. But since that would be 98% one tag I don't think that makes much sense, nor would implicating the other tags cause much flooding.
I don't think it makes much sense to tag things like post #10525139 as vore since it's primarily a fetish tag and things like that are just done for comedy. I don't know what a new tag for those posts would be called, though.
Talulah said in forum #448963:
They're named similarly because they're related. If we wanted to be pedantic over it, vore would be named oral vore and they'd all imply a vore base tag. But since that would be 98% one tag I don't think that makes much sense, nor would implicating the other tags cause much flooding.
I don't think it makes much sense to tag things like post #10525139 as vore since it's primarily a fetish tag and things like that are just done for comedy. I don't know what a new tag for those posts would be called, though.
vore is for someone being eaten, and possibly digested in a sexual way.
unbirthing, cock vore and anal vore are something completely different from that. Nobody is being "ingested" via cock vore, judging by the results we have those poor bastards end up trapped in the balls, not the stomach.
To me this implication is like saying that peeing should imply vomiting, or anal should imply oral. They are completely different fetishes, and I doubt someone searching for vore wants to see cock vore.
nonamethanks said in forum #448981:
vore is for someone being eaten, and possibly digested in a sexual way.
unbirthing, cock vore and anal vore are something completely different from that. Nobody is being "ingested" via cock vore, judging by the results we have those poor bastards end up trapped in the balls, not the stomach.To me this implication is like saying that peeing should imply vomiting, or anal should imply oral.
Well this isn't how sites like aryion, e621, or furaffinity use that term, all of which consider it a blanket term. Hell, even Wikipedia calls them subcategories.
Yeah, in my brain, this is a subcategory of an overarching fetish. The vast majority of people with the fetish would say the exact same thing I currently am. And I'm certain the blacklisters do not want to learn far more about a kink they dislike than they have to, which means it'd be way easier to just imply all of them together as most other places already do just fine. All of them are derived from a very similar fantasy scenario, even if the methodology differs.
I personally think it would be better to just group them all together as vore is already considered borderline content as is, and I don't think people who dislike this sort of thing should be exposed to people getting swallowed up by dicks anymore than they have to.
I haven't even mentioned how some cock vore has the victim churned up into cum as a form of digestion. Unbirthing can have a similar effect, just in case you weren't sold on them being a similar fantasy as regular old vore. You're welcome!
Talulah said in forum #448963:
I don't think it makes much sense to tag things like post #10525139 as vore since it's primarily a fetish tag and things like that are just done for comedy. I don't know what a new tag for those posts would be called, though.
That's what I'm currently struggling to come up with. Maybe something like eating person as one of our non-sexual equivalent tags?
