WRS said in forum #421597:
The chest is bad, there is a 90 degree angle bend on the spine, the proportions are bad, and the left hand scares me. The right leg is also just a massive blotch of grey. I know you tend to disagree with most people on aspects about anatomy but that doesn't make it any less bad. There are far better examples of good anatomy even with the style.
I could let things like the 90 degree spine and the hips slide with the style, but it was more things like the chest and hands being obviously bad that made me not like it. My stance on anatomy for more regular styles is usually to do with things being possible for even just a slightly flexible person, or to do with how much it actually affects the overall image. For the example you responded with, I think there's a chance I'd approve if it was drawn better overall but will never know because it's not.
Mr.Ritsuka said in forum #421604:
I also think that maybe we need more approvers ?
Last night I posted post #10917877 and post #10917958,as well as post #10916433 earlier that day,and so far they are still pending approvals. While I know the thread is mostly for deleted posts. I also think that post #10917877 and post #10916433 both came from artists that got are frequently uploaded and approved . I do hope these two arts could be approved. In addition,if I were to “ask” some approvers to review and approve some of my pending posts. What thread should I go ?
I personally think approvals are in a good place right now. A batch of new approvers I don't feel would do anything but it's not my call.
This is the thread to go to but you're meant to wait until they're actually status:deleted and not pending still. I don't like post #10916433 for the arms, but it's also not really a style I like either.
Snoozing said in forum #421605:
So this first post hasn’t been deleted yet but it’s up to 3 days, I wanted to see what was wrong with it and avoid uploading anything with the same flaw in the future
SENSITIVE / QUESTIONABLE post #10904236
The following are actually deleted, for this one in particular I think it has a really nice art style but the stomach for Teto was an odd choice, it’s also my guess for why it got deleted
post #10571141
With this one I think it’s because of the colors, but I would also like someone else’s opinion of why it didn’t pass through
post #10605274
And finally this one I liked the pose and face a lot so I especially want to know for this one, my current guess was the reference image and “rgkg” style to it
EXPLICIT post #10848091
For post #10904236 I think their heads look too small, especially Kronii's. Her ass also kinda looks weird.
For post #10571141 it's the hands, specifically the fingers. The way they go around her cheeks/chin look a little weird. Maybe another approver might not think that's enough to disqualify it from approval upon appeal but I wouldn't bank on it.
adler_kr said in forum #421611:
post #10910468 - this is the best quality scan of this cover I've seen so far, it has more resolution than this version (post #904994), and it still looks like it's not going to be approved, I want to know why
You can see some crease lines from the scan.
adler_kr said in forum #421612:
post #10914783 post #10914847 post #10914925 post #10914972
these posts also looks like they're not going to be approved even though there is a couple of active posts with the art from the same artist with the same quality:
post #4060670 post #5883035 post #5883026 post #5883072
I don't think post #10914972 is as good as the one's that now have been approved.
dividebyzero said in forum #421657:
All those pictures adhere to the danbooru standards of quality. I do not see why no one is bothering to approve those pictures.
[...]
I think most of these sit on fringe, but fringe in the sense that I don't think they'd be approved, at least not by me. This includes your second message below too.
