Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Nichts said in forum #420201:

post #10167764 was deleted at the end, please reconsider this and the other posts deleted by this artists copying with I say:

"Sorry, but from my perspective it seems that this standard is only applied when a user who is not a contributor is the one posting this specific artist; I don't see them flagging posts of this artist from contributor-level users even though they have the same proportions and style."

https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts?tags=jasony+status%3Adeleted

All these posts seems to be somehow AI-made or AI-assisted to me.

nyatbn said in forum #420205:

Since I've already received six rejections for post #10858528 within eight hours, I must have misunderstood something fundamentally about what constitutes approval or rejection. Could someone please explain this to me?

you gotta give posts time. there's a lot of posts that get accepted at the last minute. a few of mine get approved post-deletion because some approver look at recently deleted work.

8 hours is basically nothing. give your posts time

pipebomb445 said in forum #420098:

post #10764926
Discord.

message from approver says you need a source added. without a source, it'll never get approved.

nyatbn said in forum #420204:

True. Many posts by contributers are below the level of posts that do not get approved on regular basis. Makes no sense...

If I had uploaded post #10860139 (just a random pick) it would be deleted instantly for various reasons (bad anatomy, quality) and i would get blamed for adding not enough tags. ;-)

Yep, and the arts will never be restored. It's even more sad than losing the slots.

B17Bomber said in forum #420208:

you gotta give posts time. there's a lot of posts that get accepted at the last minute. a few of mine get approved post-deletion because some approver look at recently deleted work.

8 hours is basically nothing. give your posts time

Usually a post just needs to be revealing enough and it will be automatically disapproved (examples: post #10825727, post #10820107, post #10821654) without any reason. No issues with non revealing posts (300+ uploads) of comparable or even lower quality.

I guess i will stick to not uploading any more posts (even if i could). Artistic skill or quality does not seem to matter at all...

nyatbn said in forum #420204:

True. Many posts by contributers are below the level of posts that do not get approved on regular basis. Makes no sense...

If I had uploaded post #10860139 (just a random pick) it would be deleted instantly for various reasons (bad anatomy, quality) and i would get blamed for adding not enough tags. ;-)

What bothers me is that the reason they give for not approving this artist's posts is that they don't like the artist's style and proportions. Okay, I can accept that, but when I see them flagging a post that's already been approved for those reasons, but I see that those reasons aren't the same for other users, in this case, contributor-level users, that's what bothers me because I don't see them flagging those users' posts.

I'm done with this topic. I've already given my reasons, and I know that this user approval system is meant to maintain quality, but seeing that the same rules aren't applied to everyone... well, I won't say any more about it. But I do want to thank the approvers who have helped me approve this artist in the past.

Nichts said in forum #420219:

I see that those reasons aren't the same for other users, in this case, contributor-level users, that's what bothers me because I don't see them flagging those users' posts.

Why are you obsessed with this train of thought? There are posts uploaded by unres that have been flagged an deleted.

post #8523114
post #8459966
post #7726934

There are also active flagged posts by unres if you look at jasony flagger:any.

I really don't understand why my posts are not approved, I genuinely want some feedback from the reviewers.

post #10835469 is not being approved, but the previous version was approved post #10496511

post #10840203 got a score of 136 within 3 days, I genuinely don't believe the problem is with the quality.

I really want an explanation as to why my submissions are not approved.

CaptainPants said in forum #420233:

I really don't understand why my posts are not approved, I genuinely want some feedback from the reviewers.

post #10835469 is not being approved, but the previous version was approved post #10496511

post #10840203 got a score of 136 within 3 days, I genuinely don't believe the problem is with the quality.

I really want an explanation as to why my submissions are not approved.

Same here,I mostly upload fate-related fan arts and illustrations. Many of which are "Good enough(Good quality,high resolution) for me." However, many of the posts are deleted after the 3 day mark. I really do not understand the standard. I agree with AI-generated of AI-assisted arts need to be deleted as soon as possible,but many of the arts that I uploaded are hand-drawn and some of them were drawn before AI generated images was even a thing:
post #10552506
post #10567606
post #10569508
post #10572987
post #10574700
post #10581170
post #10583389
post #10586251
post #10788686
post #10667419
post #10831107
post #10831119
post #10844629

Personally,some of the more glaring deletes for me,are post #10572987 , post #10831107 and post #10831119.

For post post #10572987, the artist also uploaded FGO Ishtar Fan Arts that got approved on this website, and yet. The Ereshkigal fan art drawn by the very same artists,got deleted and even appeals could not save it from being deleted. Same cases with post #10831107 and post #10831119. The same artists also drew several other FGO Ishtar fan arts that got approved,while these 2 got deleted. In addition I really do not see the problem with post #10844629 ,in which I think it does not deserved to be deleted.
Last but not least, post #10856017 was still pending approval here,and I am afraid that it too would be deleted after the 3 day mark.

Mr.Ritsuka said in forum #420236:

Same here,I mostly upload fate-related fan arts and illustrations. Many of which are "Good enough(Good quality,high resolution) for me." However, many of the posts are deleted after the 3 day mark. I really do not understand the standard. I agree with AI-generated of AI-assisted arts need to be deleted as soon as possible,but many of the arts that I uploaded are hand-drawn and some of them were drawn before AI generated images was even a thing:
post #10552506
post #10567606
post #10569508
post #10572987
post #10574700
post #10581170
post #10583389
post #10586251
post #10788686
post #10667419
post #10831107
post #10831119
post #10844629

Personally,some of the more glaring deletes for me,are post #10572987 , post #10831107 and post #10831119.

For post post #10572987, the artist also uploaded FGO Ishtar Fan Arts that got approved on this website, and yet. The Ereshkigal fan art drawn by the very same artists,got deleted and even appeals could not save it from being deleted. Same cases with post #10831107 and post #10831119. The same artists also drew several other FGO Ishtar fan arts that got approved,while these 2 got deleted. In addition I really do not see the problem with post #10844629 ,in which I think it does not deserved to be deleted.
Last but not least, post #10856017 was still pending approval here,and I am afraid that it too would be deleted after the 3 day mark.

To be honest, I can understand why some of the ones sent would not be approved, except post #10572987, that looks good enough to be here.

will this cute artist get approved?

post #10843977
post #10843968

CaptainPants said in forum #420244:

To be honest, I can understand why some of the ones sent would not be approved, except post #10572987, that looks good enough to be here.

In the case of post #10572987. I did try to appeal the post when it got deleted after the 3 day mark,but was unfortunately still got deleted.

Guys, approve this post: post #10853075, its of same series of {post #10853033 post #10853037 post #10853073 post #10853082 post #10853087}, you cant left one of them unapprove while accept the rest.

Failed appeals continue

GENERAL
post #10633374 - This is this artist's style, everything else was approved, and my appeal of one of its sister posts was also approved, leaving this one on its own Thanks!
post #10640763 - Doesn't seem poor quality to me, if it is a bit rough (given it's birthday art)
post #10672644 - This one I don't get; it's a stylized semi-impressionist style and it doesn't look amateur to me either

SENSITIVE
post #10677023 - Not sure what's wrong with this one either

QUESTIONABLE
post #10668450 - Not sure what's wrong with this one either

EXPLICIT
post #10636738 - Not sure what's inadequate quality about this; there is an alt at the source but it's black and white instead of black and purple so

Thanks!

For me, it's just that the standards seem inconsistent.

I have trouble wrapping my head around how post #10796257 gets approved, but post #10818202 (Explicit) doesn't.

StarfishAtLarge said in forum #420286:

For me, it's just that the standards seem inconsistent.

I have trouble wrapping my head around how post #10796257 gets approved, but post #10818202 (Explicit) doesn't.

Um, the first post is still quality enough for me though;)))

https://safebooru.donmai.us/posts/10862351 looks a lot worse than some of mine. Also the two rare super sentai ones were drawn by literal kids, weird how no one has noticed that vampire character yet

lullabyfan said in forum #420061:

Could someone tell me what's wrong with these? I honestly don't get it

post #10800053
post #10800121
post #10800152
post #10800294
post #10800579
post #10800825
post #10800961
post #10801055
post #10801105

It’s just that some people just really don’t like these

Mr.Ritsuka said in forum #420236:

Same here,I mostly upload fate-related fan arts and illustrations. Many of which are "Good enough(Good quality,high resolution) for me." However, many of the posts are deleted after the 3 day mark. I really do not understand the standard. I agree with AI-generated of AI-assisted arts need to be deleted as soon as possible,but many of the arts that I uploaded are hand-drawn and some of them were drawn before AI generated images was even a thing:
post #10552506
post #10567606
post #10569508
post #10572987
post #10574700
post #10581170
post #10583389
post #10586251
post #10788686
post #10667419
post #10831107
post #10831119
post #10844629

Personally,some of the more glaring deletes for me,are post #10572987 , post #10831107 and post #10831119.

For post post #10572987, the artist also uploaded FGO Ishtar Fan Arts that got approved on this website, and yet. The Ereshkigal fan art drawn by the very same artists,got deleted and even appeals could not save it from being deleted. Same cases with post #10831107 and post #10831119. The same artists also drew several other FGO Ishtar fan arts that got approved,while these 2 got deleted. In addition I really do not see the problem with post #10844629 ,in which I think it does not deserved to be deleted.
Last but not least, post #10856017 was still pending approval here,and I am afraid that it too would be deleted after the 3 day mark.

Yeah, I agree with you on that, however, some fan arts are “low quality” according to the approvers

post #10831926

This post should be approved because many of the artist’s works are approved here