Coconut cup to coconut

BUR #54896 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

create implication coconut_cup -> coconut

Makes sense to me.

BUR #54897 has been rejected.

create implication coconut -> fruit

Makes sense to me.

Should we also imply tomato to fruit then? Just because it may be technically correct doesn't mean it's how people generally categorize it.

Ylimegirl said in forum #418732:

Should we also imply tomato to fruit then? Just because it may be technically correct doesn't mean it's how people generally categorize it.

That would seem the logic, but if we do that we'd also need to tag images depicting the peanut pods and pea pods as fruit as well since legumes are also technically a fruit.

We use the culinary definition of fruit, not the botanical one.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fruit#Botanical_vs._culinary

Afaik coconuts are culinary fruits. You can use them in desserts and stuff.

The wiki for the page also calls it a fruit.

Shouldn't this tag also imply fruit cup?

Unbreakable said in forum #418745:

Shouldn't this tag also imply fruit cup?

That makes total sense ngl.

BUR #54903 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

create implication coconut_cup -> fruit_cup

makes sense to me.

Unbreakable said in forum #418745:

Shouldn't this tag also imply fruit cup?

Seems a poor naming choice for that tag when the term is commonly used for other things. Some posts under the tag are using the more common usages of the term: post #7832883, post #8080210, post #9116970. The tag is also being used for non-culinary fruits such as pumpkins/squash, post #3681285, post #2892793, post #1536307. If these should be under the tag, using "fruit" in the name runs the risk of someone thinking everything under it should also be tagged fruit.

GreyOmega said in forum #418751:

Seems a poor naming choice for that tag when the term is commonly used for other things. Some posts under the tag are using the more common usages of the term: post #7832883, post #8080210, post #9116970. The tag is also being used for non-culinary fruits such as pumpkins/squash, post #3681285, post #2892793, post #1536307. If these should be under the tag, using "fruit" in the name runs the risk of someone thinking everything under it should also be tagged fruit.

It's in the wiki though and often used that way? Fruit cup dessert can be qualified easily can't it? Vs literal fruit used as a cup.

BUR #55964 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

create alias fruit_cup -> fruit_as_cup
remove alias fruit_cup -> fruit_as_cup

Maybe this will help then. We'll need a new tag for a cup full of pieces of fruit.

The bulk update request #54896 (forum #418729) has been approved by @nonamethanks.

The bulk update request #54897 (forum #418730) has been rejected by @nonamethanks.

The bulk update request #54903 (forum #418750) has been approved by @nonamethanks.

The bulk update request #55964 (forum #422615) has been approved by @nonamethanks.

I made cup of fruit for the other stuff. Not sure about the name, feel free to suggest an alias if you think you have a better name for it.

We also have fruit bowl but that's for whole fruits.