holding fruit

BUR #54420 has been approved by @evazion.

mass update holding_cherry -> cherry
create alias holding_cherry -> holding_fruit
mass update holding_grape -> grapes
create alias holding_grape -> holding_fruit
create alias holding_lemon -> holding_fruit
mass update holding_orange -> orange_(fruit)
create alias holding_orange -> holding_fruit
create alias holding_watermelon -> holding_fruit

I don't think we need this level of granularity for holding fruit. holding_apple and holding_peach are already aliased to holding fruit. While searching for previous BURs, I found topic #24496 which shows people may have different opinions on this. I'll propose an alternate BUR below for implication. (note, no mass updates for lemon or watermelon since those are already all tagged with their respective fruits either manually or by implication).

edit, the implication BUR doesn't seem to be working right now. When I submit it, it just redirects me to this page without making the BUR. I don't have the time to fix it right now, so I'll try again later.

Ok, the second BUR still isn't working. I'm not sure what's happening. This is the body of the BUR I'm trying to make:

imply holding_cherry -> cherry
imply holding_cherry -> holding_fruit
imply holding_grape -> grapes
imply holding_grape -> holding_fruit
imply holding_lemon -> lemon
imply holding_lemon -> holding_fruit
imply holding_orange -> orange_(fruit)
imply holding_orange -> holding_fruit

As I said in the original post, it's just redirecting me to this page without making the BUR; there's not even any sort of error message.

Placeholder1996 said in forum #416931:

Ok, the second BUR still isn't working. I'm not sure what's happening. This is the body of the BUR I'm trying to make:

imply holding_cherry -> cherry
imply holding_cherry -> holding_fruit
imply holding_grape -> grapes
imply holding_grape -> holding_fruit
imply holding_lemon -> lemon
imply holding_lemon -> holding_fruit
imply holding_orange -> orange_(fruit)
imply holding_orange -> holding_fruit

As I said in the original post, it's just redirecting me to this page without making the BUR; there's not even any sort of error message.

Several tags you’re trying to imply don’t have wikis. They must have wikis in order to make the BUR properly.

Holding watermelon is pretty different from holding cherry, but not doing this would mean we would have to contend with separate holding tags for very similar fruits, like orange vs mandarin orange, lemon vs lime, strawberry vs raspberry, melon vs watermelon, etc.

The bulk update request #54420 (forum #416925) has been approved by @evazion.

BUR #54519 has been approved by @evazion.

remove implication holding_fruit -> watermelon

It seems there was a mistake somewhere.

sinapp said in forum #417288:

BUR #54519 has been approved by @evazion.

remove implication holding_fruit -> watermelon

It seems there was a mistake somewhere.

Holding watermelon implied watermelon, which carried over when the former was aliased to holding fruit…

aster1a said in forum #417292:

Holding watermelon implied watermelon, which carried over when the former was aliased to holding fruit…

Damnit, I missed that when I made the original bur. many apologies

The bulk update request #54519 (forum #417288) has been approved by @evazion.

Yeah, this is precisely why I removed implications first before aliasing away some granular holding tags just a week and one day ago (forum #415989) but I realise this isn't always apparent to people (issue #4206). I missed this topic on my regular forum read so I wasn't there to sound the alarm of doing it this way.