Should gendered animal terms (bull, rooster, cow,etc) imply an umbrella species tag?

Posted under Tags

Zalza

BUR #46635 has been rejected.

create implication cow -> cattle
create implication bull -> cattle

simmilar topic forum #371493

Rooster currently implies chicken, seems to be the way to go. Alternatively bull should imply or be aliased to cow, but I think it's a bit dumb to search cow and get bulls with no cows. Unsure wether people want a hen tag.

Reply
Zalza Nexaman Pokemon by gender ratio The Bob Confetto trapster77 user 881800 CommentaryRequest Bernkastel83 Knowledge Seeker NO AI ON DANBOORU
Zalza

BUR #46637 has been rejected.

create implication hen -> chicken
mass update favgroup:43766 -> hen

Keeping the "hen" tag seperate as I am not sure if people want it. There is also the issue of things that look like hens vs depictions of gender neutral things like cliche bloby cartoony chickens post #5735661 post #8974315 or the minecraft chicken. The favgroup only contains the former.

This alligns with what is currently tagged rooster (distinct, non blob) post #2596788 post #2586392

Reply
Zalza Pokemon by gender ratio NO AI ON DANBOORU The Bob Confetto CommentaryRequest MiiaBestLamia user 881800 Knowledge Seeker
MiiaBestLamia

Zalza said:

BUR #46637 has been rejected.

create implication hen -> chicken
mass update favgroup:43766 -> hen

Keeping the "hen" tag seperate as I am not sure if people want it. There is also the issue of things that look like hens vs depictions of gender neutral things like cliche bloby cartoony chickens post #5735661 post #8974315 or the minecraft chicken. The favgroup only contains the former.

This alligns with what is currently tagged rooster (distinct, non blob) post #2596788 post #2586392

Seems like a logical BUR. There's a bunch of existing examples, like peacock/peahen, the aforementioned bull/cow. Plenty of missing examples too, like lion/lioness, buck/doe. This isn't animalbooru, so maybe there's no reason to go into "so much" detail, but at the same time a precedent for this kind of tagging exists, and the visual differences are very distinct.

Reply
Zalza

MiiaBestLamia said:

Seems like a logical BUR. There's a bunch of existing examples, like peacock/peahen, the aforementioned bull/cow. Plenty of missing examples too, like lion/lioness, buck/doe. This isn't animalbooru, so maybe there's no reason to go into "so much" detail, but at the same time a precedent for this kind of tagging exists, and the visual differences are very distinct.

Seems the culture has changed a little bit in allowing for more detailed tags but it might vary on a case by case basis. In my opinion IF a tag does exist, you should be able to search for that animal and it's gendered term. I'll add peafowl but I'm not sure if that will be too one sided.

Reply
1