Split alternate_breast_size

BUR #43522 is pending approval.

deprecate alternate_breast_size
mass update alternate_breast_size solo (flat_chest or small_breasts) -> -alternate_breast_size smaller_breasts
mass update alternate_breast_size solo (gigantic_breasts or huge_breasts ) -> -alternate_breast_size larger_breasts

The best way to quickly describe it is this quote from a pre-discussion on Discord:

nonamethanks said:

nobody is going to danbooru and saying "fumimi, pull up all results of old women turned into lolis, and teenagers with giant breasts"

The BUR should take care of extreme cases of and , which would cover 75% of existing alternate_breast_size posts, with the assumption of one size difference being not big enough to be tagged.

The problem with smaller breasts & larger breasts is that it makes these tags sound like they're for a comparison between two characters, rather than a depiction different from canon. I don't know what else we could use, but we should think carefully about the naming because there's other tags that need to be split, like alternate height and alternate muscle size.

smaller breasts than canon/larger breasts than canon would be the clearest version of this and it would also be easily adaptable for other tags (more muscular than canon/taller than canon), but it feels very verbose.

BUR #43523 is pending approval.

deprecate alternate_breast_size
mass update alternate_breast_size solo (flat_chest or small_breasts) -> -alternate_breast_size smaller_breasts_than_canon
mass update alternate_breast_size solo (gigantic_breasts or huge_breasts ) -> -alternate_breast_size larger_breasts_than_canon

Alternate proposal.

Please feel free to submit counterBURs if you have a better idea.

What about something like enlarged breasts and decreased breasts?

rainyd said:

What about something like enlarged breasts and decreased breasts?

That sounds like a disease or inflation.

rainyd said:

What about something like enlarged breasts and decreased breasts?

That'd be ambiguous with breast expansion and breast reduction.

I also think the name's a bit much, but I can't think of anything better format-wise. At the very least, this would be establishing a new naming format utilizing a term that isn't used so far in tags, canon.

How about these?

alternate breast size (smaller), alternate breast size (larger)

alternate height (shorter), alternate height (taller)

alternate muscle size (smaller), alternate muscle size (larger)

BUR #43525 is pending approval.

deprecate alternate_breast_size
mass update alternate_breast_size solo ~flat_chest ~small_breasts -> -alternate_breast_size alternate_breast_size_(smaller)
mass update alternate_breast_size solo ~gigantic_breasts ~huge_breasts -> -alternate_breast_size alternate_breast_size_(larger)

Just saw the request for BURs after my last post.

I think adding qualifiers is enough since the current already makes it clear it's supposed to be different from canon. It will also be easier on people already used to the current tag.

nonamethanks said:

Alternate proposal.

Please feel free to submit counterBURs if you have a better idea.

While I like the idea, those tags are quite a bit of a mouthful. The current tag is too vague so I agree there needs to be new tags

Blank_User said:

I think adding qualifiers is enough since the current already makes it clear it's supposed to be different from canon. It will also be easier on people already used to the current tag.

Probably the best idea so far. Idk how I'd simplify the tag, but I'll run ideas with some friends

nonamethanks said:

BUR #43523 is pending approval.

deprecate alternate_breast_size
mass update alternate_breast_size solo (flat_chest or small_breasts) -> -alternate_breast_size smaller_breasts_than_canon
mass update alternate_breast_size solo (gigantic_breasts or huge_breasts ) -> -alternate_breast_size larger_breasts_than_canon

Alternate proposal.

Please feel free to submit counterBURs if you have a better idea.

A little late to the discussion but if these don't go through but BUR #43525 does I would like to see these as utility aliases. Presumably it will be a lot easier to type "larger_bre.." + tab than "alternate_breast_size_(l" + tab. I'm not sure if autocomplete would suggest the full tag just by typing "larger" anyways. If it does then no need for an alias ig.