Undershirt colors: implication or nuke?

BUR #44971 is pending approval.

create implication black_undershirt -> undershirt
create implication white_undershirt -> undershirt
create implication red_undershirt -> undershirt
create implication blue_undershirt -> undershirt
create implication purple_undershirt -> undershirt
create implication grey_undershirt -> undershirt
create implication green_undershirt -> undershirt
create implication pink_undershirt -> undershirt
create implication yellow_undershirt -> undershirt
create implication orange_undershirt -> undershirt

Black and white are very used ones, unlike the other colors. Probably because they’re the most common. Are these good tags?

BUR #44972 is pending approval.

mass update ~black_undershirt ~white_undershirt ~red_undershirt ~blue_undershirt ~purple_undershirt ~grey_undershirt ~green_undershirt ~pink_undershirt ~yellow_undershirt ~orange_undershirt -> undershirt
nuke black_undershirt
nuke white_undershirt
nuke red_undershirt
nuke blue_undershirt
nuke purple_undershirt
nuke grey_undershirt
nuke green_undershirt
nuke pink_undershirt
nuke yellow_undershirt
nuke orange_undershirt

Alternate BUR. Almost 6000 posts lack undershirt, hence the update.

aster1a said:

BUR #44971 is pending approval.

create implication black_undershirt -> undershirt
create implication white_undershirt -> undershirt
create implication red_undershirt -> undershirt
create implication blue_undershirt -> undershirt
create implication purple_undershirt -> undershirt
create implication grey_undershirt -> undershirt
create implication green_undershirt -> undershirt
create implication pink_undershirt -> undershirt
create implication yellow_undershirt -> undershirt
create implication orange_undershirt -> undershirt

Black and white are very used ones, unlike the other colors. Probably because they’re the most common. Are these good tags?

I don't know to be honest. Maybe colored undershirt for everything besides black & white? The colored tags aren't widely tagged at all.

Placeholder1996 said:

I don't know to be honest. Maybe colored undershirt for everything besides black & white? The colored tags aren't widely tagged at all.

I was thinking about colored_undershirt, but I haven’t seen colored_* stuff used for clothes. Closest I’ve seen are accessories and colored shoe soles.

BUR #44973 is pending approval.

create implication black_undershirt -> undershirt
create implication white_undershirt -> undershirt
create alias red_undershirt -> colored_undershirt
create alias blue_undershirt -> colored_undershirt
create alias purple_undershirt -> colored_undershirt
create alias grey_undershirt -> colored_undershirt
create alias green_undershirt -> colored_undershirt
create alias pink_undershirt -> colored_undershirt
create alias yellow_undershirt -> colored_undershirt
create alias orange_undershirt -> colored_undershirt
create implication colored_undershirt -> undershirt

Just putting this up for voting purposes; hopefully I got the formatting right.

An undershirt is still just a shirt, not a unique piece of clothing. I see no reason why there should be special tags for it instead of just using the normal colored shirt tags.

I agree with the above, also black undershirt keeps getting in the way when I want to tag black umbrella.

I could go either nuke or colored_undershirt. I think that what characters like Kaworu have going on seems like a taggable concept, but black/white undershirt is absolute tag padding.

colored_udnershirt is so nondescript that it borders on useless, what is gonna happen is that down the line it will have several thousand unrelated tags with the only common thing is characters wearing an undershirt of any color besides white and we are gonna end up having to nuke it or split it anyway.

Makes sense. The main issue for me is so many posts tagged with undershirt colors but not undershirt. Black and white were tagged almost as if they were separate tags from undershirt entirely! And looking at the posts, I guess these colors aren’t that useful.

aster1a said:

Makes sense. The main issue for me is so many posts tagged with undershirt colors but not undershirt. Black and white were tagged almost as if they were separate tags from undershirt entirely! And looking at the posts, I guess these colors aren’t that useful.

Most taggers probably incorrectly assumed the colored tags implied the base tag.