Given the precedent set by topic #18277 and topic #19119, among others, the argument of "despite looking like another character, in their source material they are a separate character" does not hold water.
Posted under Tags
Given the precedent set by topic #18277 and topic #19119, among others, the argument of "despite looking like another character, in their source material they are a separate character" does not hold water.
The bulk update request #15469 (forum #234722) has been approved by @evazion.
BUR #15493 has been approved by @evazion.
create implication m500_(daydreaming_in_class)_(girls'_frontline) -> m500_(girls'_frontline)
create implication rmb-93_(cross_the_milky_way)_(girls'_frontline) -> rmb-93_(girls'_frontline)
create implication rmb-93_(moonlit_lover_beyond_reach)_(girls'_frontline) -> rmb-93_(girls'_frontline)
create implication ns2000_(hundred-flavor_curry_bunny)_(girls'_frontline) -> ns2000_(girls'_frontline)
create implication m1897_(electric_witch)_(girls'_frontline) -> m1897_(girls'_frontline)
create implication m1897_(sentinel_of_the_sky)_(girls'_frontline) -> m1897_(girls'_frontline)
create implication ts12_(bouquet_for_the_galaxy)_(girls'_frontline) -> ts12_(girls'_frontline)
create implication m37_(summer_parader)_(girls'_frontline) -> m37_(girls'_frontline)
create implication m37_(a_long_vacation_with_ithaca)_(girls'_frontline) -> m37_(girls'_frontline)
create implication m590_(angel's_trumpet)_(girls'_frontline) -> m590_(girls'_frontline)
create implication m590_(recreation_after_school)_(girls'_frontline) -> m590_(girls'_frontline)
create implication type_97_shotgun_(ingenious_stratagem_no.97)_(girls'_frontline) -> type_97_shotgun_(girls'_frontline)
create implication type_97_shotgun_(drunken_petals)_(girls'_frontline) -> type_97_shotgun_(girls'_frontline)
create implication m1014_(snow_moon_and_flowers)_(girls'_frontline) -> m1014_(girls'_frontline)
create implication m1014_(heartbeat_before_the_angel_statue)_(girls'_frontline) -> m1014_(girls'_frontline)
create implication spas-12_(midsummer_fruit)_(girls'_frontline) -> spas-12_(girls'_frontline)
create implication spas-12_(marching_band)_(girls'_frontline) -> spas-12_(girls'_frontline)
create implication spas-12_(goblin_huntress)_(girls'_frontline) -> spas-12_(girls'_frontline)
create implication super-shorty_(crossing_in_labyrinth)_(girls'_frontline) -> super-shorty_(girls'_frontline)
create implication super-shorty_(bad_cop_for_life)_(girls'_frontline) -> super-shorty_(girls'_frontline)
create implication usas-12_(vrain_power)_(girls'_frontline) -> usas-12_(girls'_frontline)
create implication defender_(lily's_reverie)_(girls'_frontline) -> defender_(girls'_frontline)
create implication defender_(stardust_veil)_(girls'_frontline) -> defender_(girls'_frontline)
create implication v-pm5_(soaring_starfish)_(girls'_frontline) -> v-pm5_(girls'_frontline)
create implication v-pm5_(feathers_in_first_dream)_(girls'_frontline) -> v-pm5_(girls'_frontline)
create implication super_nova_(streaking_meteor)_(girls'_frontline) -> super_nova_(girls'_frontline)
create implication m1887_(law_of_exorcism)_(girls'_frontline) -> m1887_(girls'_frontline)
create implication aa-12_(the_sun_never_rises)_(girls'_frontline) -> aa-12_(girls'_frontline)
create implication aa-12_(smokeless_lollipop)_(girls'_frontline) -> aa-12_(girls'_frontline)
create implication fp-6_(satellite_of_love)_(girls'_frontline) -> fp-6_(girls'_frontline)
create implication s.a.t.8_(wintersweet)_(girls'_frontline) -> s.a.t.8_(girls'_frontline)
create implication s.a.t.8_(pumpkin_skewers)_(girls'_frontline) -> s.a.t.8_(girls'_frontline)
create implication s.a.t.8_(maiden's_secret)_(girls'_frontline) -> s.a.t.8_(girls'_frontline)
create implication saiga-12_(crimson_navigator)_(girls'_frontline) -> saiga-12_(girls'_frontline)
create implication saiga-12_(arbiter_of_twilight)_(girls'_frontline) -> saiga-12_(girls'_frontline)
create implication saiga-12_(visitor_of_bountiful_blossoms)_(girls'_frontline) -> saiga-12_(girls'_frontline)
create implication m870_(pumpkin_fortress)_(girls'_frontline) -> m870_(girls'_frontline)
create implication caws_(120_winter_gifts)_(girls'_frontline) -> caws_(girls'_frontline)
create implication caws_(striker_in_adversity)_(girls'_frontline) -> caws_(girls'_frontline)
create implication dp-12_(echeveria_lantern)_(girls'_frontline) -> dp-12_(girls'_frontline)
create implication dp-12_(keeper_of_the_sanzu_river)_(girls'_frontline) -> dp-12_(girls'_frontline)
create implication dp-12_(morning_fable)_(girls'_frontline) -> dp-12_(girls'_frontline)
create implication ltlx_7000_(night-tide_invitation)_(girls'_frontline) -> ltlx_7000_(girls'_frontline)
create implication ltlx_7000_(dancing_shrine_maiden)_(girls'_frontline) -> ltlx_7000_(girls'_frontline)
The clothes reference the character implied. Shotguns next- The last of the gun types.
Currently inapplicable:
No skins
ks-23_(girls'_frontline)
six12_(girls'_frontline)
hsm10_(girls'_frontline)
liberator_(girls'_frontline)
hk512_(girls'_frontline)
mag-7_(girls'_frontline)
uts-15_(girls'_frontline)
ksg_(girls'_frontline)
fo-12_(girls'_frontline)
m26-mass_(girls'_frontline)
mk3a1_(girls'_frontline)
spas-15__(girls'_frontline)
Not represented on danbooru or not named in EN servers yet
Imply m6_asw_(survival_on_the_wild_seas)_(girls'_frontline) -> m6_asw_(girls'_frontline)
While that's being decided, it may be worth discussing the fact that Elphelt Valentine, one of the two characters that crossed over as a unit for the game's Guilty Gear x BlazBlue collab, has two skin tags for the ones she has in GFL, and both have the Girls' Frontline modifier because that's where they are skins in (which makes it look like she's a character in GFL due to the tag's formatting) - elphelt_valentine_(*)_(girls'_frontline). What should we do with them?
I personally think that it isn't a good idea to have either of these tags hang around, because it might lead to skin-tag spillover from gachas to elsewhere (like we've seen recently with someone making skin tags for the fucking Mario series...), or adding modifiers to modifier-less characters that imply they're part of another copyright altogether. One of these skins is already easily searchable by just searching elphelt_valentine sangvis_ferri anyway, so it wouldn't make that one (the unique one of the two) any less accessible.
I also just realized that the reason why those two tags are formatted like that is because of Azur Lane doing the same with Kizuna Ai's skins, kizuna_ai_(*)_(azur_lane), which led to her getting outfit tags - so any decision made on Elphelt would also impact Kizuna Ai's AL skins (of which only the Festive one appears to be unique to AL).
Updated
The bulk update request #15493 (forum #234805) has been approved by @evazion.
So the same thing should be done with 10000 Azur lane skins. (and maybe mass update them with official alternate costume tag while we are at it?
Aken_Bosch said:
So the same thing should be done with 10000 Azur lane skins. (and maybe mass update them with official alternate costume tag while we are at it?
Are you volunteering? I'm sticking with copyrights I'm familiar with.
Todo:
Updated
BUR #16224 has been approved by @nonamethanks.
rename aug_para_(sawanobori_in_the_autumn)_(girls'_frontline) -> aug_para_(river_trekking_in_fall)_(girls'_frontline)
rename sl8_(waiting_for_you_in_the_corner_of_the_world)_(girls'_frontline) -> sl8_(a_doll_sat_still)_(girls'_frontline)
rename sp9_(dream_sleeping_in_the_galaxy)_(girls'_frontline) -> sp9_(slumbering_starry_dream)_(girls'_frontline)
rename rex_zero_1_(pulse-pounding_trilogy)_(girls'_frontline) -> rex_zero_1_(heart-aflutter_trilogy)_(girls'_frontline)
rename model_l_(floating_into_the_blue_sky)_(girls'_frontline) -> model_l_(up_into_the_blue_sky)_(girls'_frontline)
Official names, courtesy of GirlsFrontlineE on twitter. Search for "A Guide to a Wonderful Date" (The skin collection name)
BUR #16238 has been approved by @nonamethanks.
create implication p30_(devil's_ring_pop)_(girls'_frontline) -> p30_(girls'_frontline)
create implication k5_(array_of_venus)_(girls'_frontline) -> k5_(girls'_frontline)
create implication type_79_(gazing_from_the_dust)_(girls'_frontline) -> type_79_(girls'_frontline)
create implication lusa_(new_star_defender)_(girls'_frontline) -> lusa_(girls'_frontline)
create implication falcon_(song_of_the_morning_dew)_(girls'_frontline) -> falcon_(girls'_frontline)
create implication mondragon_m1908_(twilight_after_rain)_(girls'_frontline) -> mondragon_m1908_(girls'_frontline)
create implication qbu-88_(explorer_of_the_wild)_(girls'_frontline) -> qbu-88_(girls'_frontline)
create implication qbu-88_(dance_of_the_trumpet_vine)_(girls'_frontline) -> qbu-88_(girls'_frontline)
create implication ak_5_(rainbow-weaving_flower_fairy)_(girls'_frontline) -> ak_5_(girls'_frontline)
create implication g11_(autumn_nap_as_you_will_xi)_(girls'_frontline) -> g11_(girls'_frontline)
create implication s-acr_(make_a_sweet_wish)_(girls'_frontline) -> s-acr_(girls'_frontline)
create implication s-acr_(wind-chasing_witch)_(girls'_frontline) -> s-acr_(girls'_frontline)
create implication m1895_cb_(slipper_orchid)_(girls'_frontline) -> m1895_cb_(girls'_frontline)
create implication lewis_(gallop_of_gingko_leaves_and_autumn_winds)_(girls'_frontline) -> lewis_(girls'_frontline)
The clothes reference the character implied. After uploading artwork to represent these skins, we're good to implicate.
The bulk update request #16238 (forum #238531) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
The bulk update request #16224 (forum #238469) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
The bulk update request #15464 (forum #234715) has been rejected by @DanbooruBot.
BUR #17369 has been approved by @nonamethanks.
deprecate mod3_(girls'_frontline)
Following on from topic #18013 which spelled the end of KanColle's Remodel tag, and topic #23995 which sealed the fate of Arknights' Elite II tag, with the combined efforts of myself, baconmeh2, and eidolon (who handled the remaining couple of posts neither me nor bacon could access), there are now MOD3 character tags for Girls' Frontline. Formally deprecating the MOD3 general tag should ensure it doesn't get repopulated again.
Updated
The bulk update request #17369 (forum #243756) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
BUR #18099 has been approved by @nonamethanks.
create implication ak-15_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> ak-15_(girls'_frontline)
create implication an-94_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> an-94_(girls'_frontline)
create implication as_val_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> as_val_(girls'_frontline)
create implication beretta_model_38_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> beretta_model_38_(girls'_frontline)
create implication bren_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> bren_(girls'_frontline)
create implication c96_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> c96_(girls'_frontline)
create implication colt_revolver_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> colt_revolver_(girls'_frontline)
create implication dp-12_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> dp-12_(girls'_frontline)
create implication f1_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> f1_(girls'_frontline)
create implication fn-49_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> fn-49_(girls'_frontline)
create implication g11_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> g11_(girls'_frontline)
create implication g3_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> g3_(girls'_frontline)
create implication g36_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> g36_(girls'_frontline)
create implication g36c_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> g36c_(girls'_frontline)
create implication galil_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> galil_(girls'_frontline)
create implication gepard_m1_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> gepard_m1_(girls'_frontline)
create implication gsh-18_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> gsh-18_(girls'_frontline)
create implication hanyang_type_88_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> hanyang_type_88_(girls'_frontline)
create implication hk416_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> hk416_(girls'_frontline)
create implication idw_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> idw_(girls'_frontline)
create implication kar98k_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> kar98k_(girls'_frontline)
create implication ksvk_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> ksvk_(girls'_frontline)
create implication lee-enfield_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> lee-enfield_(girls'_frontline)
create implication lwmmg_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> lwmmg_(girls'_frontline)
create implication m14_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> m14_(girls'_frontline)
create implication m1897_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> m1897_(girls'_frontline)
create implication m1911_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> m1911_(girls'_frontline)
create implication m1918_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> m1918_(girls'_frontline)
create implication m4_sopmod_ii_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> m4_sopmod_ii_(girls'_frontline)
create implication m4a1_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> m4a1_(girls'_frontline)
create implication m500_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> m500_(girls'_frontline)
create implication m950a_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> m950a_(girls'_frontline)
create implication makarov_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> makarov_(girls'_frontline)
create implication mg3_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> mg3_(girls'_frontline)
create implication mg4_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> mg4_(girls'_frontline)
create implication micro_uzi_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> micro_uzi_(girls'_frontline)
create implication mosin-nagant_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> mosin-nagant_(girls'_frontline)
create implication mp-443_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> mp-443_(girls'_frontline)
create implication mp-446_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> mp-446_(girls'_frontline)
create implication mp5_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> mp5_(girls'_frontline)
create implication nagant_revolver_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> nagant_revolver_(girls'_frontline)
create implication ntw-20_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> ntw-20_(girls'_frontline)
create implication obr_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> obr_(girls'_frontline)
create implication pp-19_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> pp-19_(girls'_frontline)
create implication ppk_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> ppk_(girls'_frontline)
create implication ppsh-41_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> ppsh-41_(girls'_frontline)
create implication ribeyrolles_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> ribeyrolles_(girls'_frontline)
create implication rmb-93_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> rmb-93_(girls'_frontline)
create implication ro635_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> ro635_(girls'_frontline)
create implication st_ar-15_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> st_ar-15_(girls'_frontline)
create implication stechkin_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> stechkin_(girls'_frontline)
create implication sten_mkii_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> sten_mkii_(girls'_frontline)
create implication stg44_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> stg44_(girls'_frontline)
create implication suomi_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> suomi_(girls'_frontline)
create implication super_sass_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> super_sass_(girls'_frontline)
create implication sv-98_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> sv-98_(girls'_frontline)
create implication type_56_carbine_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> type_56_carbine_(girls'_frontline)
create implication type_56-1_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> type_56-1_(girls'_frontline)
create implication type_64_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> type_64_(girls'_frontline)
create implication type_80_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> type_80_(girls'_frontline)
create implication type_97_shotgun_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> type_97_shotgun_(girls'_frontline)
create implication ump45_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> ump45_(girls'_frontline)
create implication ump9_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> ump9_(girls'_frontline)
create implication welrod_mkii_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> welrod_mkii_(girls'_frontline)
create implication xm3_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> xm3_(girls'_frontline)
create implication xm8_(mod3)_(girls'_frontline) -> xm8_(girls'_frontline)
The clothes reference the character implied. MOD3 edition.
BUR #18107 has been approved by @nonamethanks.
create implication morridow_(boss)_(girls'_frontline) -> morridow_(girls'_frontline)
create implication nemeum_swap_(girls'_frontline) -> nemeum_(girls'_frontline)
rename lady_grey_(girls'_frontline) -> lady_gray_(girls'_frontline)
rename jormungand_(girls'_frontline) -> jormungandr_(girls'_frontline)
create implication ump9_(bee's_knees)_(girls'_frontline) -> ump9_(girls'_frontline)
create implication ump40_(moon_river)_(girls'_frontline) -> ump40_(girls'_frontline)
create implication ump45_(corona_sunset)_(girls'_frontline) -> ump45_(girls'_frontline)
create implication hk416_(white_negroni)_(girls'_frontline) -> hk416_(girls'_frontline)
create implication g11_(mind_eraser)_(girls'_frontline) -> g11_(girls'_frontline)
create implication aug_para_(pisco_sour)_(girls'_frontline) -> aug_para_(girls'_frontline)
create implication sl8_(spectral_fizz)_(girls'_frontline) -> sl8_(girls'_frontline)
create implication vhs_(whiskey_float)_(girls'_frontline) -> vhs_(girls'_frontline)
create implication mk3a1_(the_art_of_mk3a1_maintenance)_(girls'_frontline) -> mk3a1_(girls'_frontline)
create implication tabuk_(pet_trainer's_daily_life)_(girls'_frontline) -> tabuk_(girls'_frontline)
create implication type_95_(kite_flyer_in_spring)_(girls'_frontline) -> type_95_(girls'_frontline)
create implication vsk-94_(dance_like_the_blazing_sun)_(girls'_frontline) -> vsk-94_(girls'_frontline)
create implication px4_storm_(guardian_of_hibernation_dreams)_(girls'_frontline) -> px4_storm_(girls'_frontline)
create implication type_56_carbine_(panda-eared_seamstress)_(girls'_frontline) -> type_56_carbine_(girls'_frontline)
create implication evo_3_(apricot_summer)_(girls'_frontline) -> evo_3_(girls'_frontline)
create implication colt_walker_(the_next_seven_days)_(girls'_frontline) -> colt_walker_(girls'_frontline)
create implication c-93_(glistening_encounter)_(girls'_frontline) -> c-93_(girls'_frontline)
create implication ak74m_(trident_and_fish_slicer)_(girls'_frontline) -> ak74m_(girls'_frontline)
create implication cf05_(floating_melody)_(girls'_frontline) -> cf05_(girls'_frontline)
create implication hs.50_(honey-colored_ocean_heart)_(girls'_frontline) -> hs.50_(girls'_frontline)
create implication m6_asw_(survival_on_the_wild_seas)_(girls'_frontline) -> m6_asw_(girls'_frontline)
create implication savage_99_(savage's_fry_craving)_(girls'_frontline) -> savage_99_(girls'_frontline)
create implication iws_2000_(sand_castle_terminator)_(girls'_frontline) -> iws_2000_(girls'_frontline)
create implication sterling_(melting_in_the_summer_heat)_(girls'_frontline) -> sterling_(girls'_frontline)
The clothes reference the character implied. Morridow (Boss) is still Morridow, and name corrections on Lady Gray and Jormungandr.