MFZbdude said:
post #2487967. According to the status bar, it was only ever reviewed twice, but I'm wondering if there's actually anything wrong with it before I appeal.
The area around her waist seems off, it isn't quite successful in showing "she's sitting" and strays into "she has really short legs" territory. Beyond that, somehow it seems kind of plain to me. It's not a very exciting addition to a copyright tag that has half a million posts.
kudus said:
i know this thread for post keep getting deleted and this is my first time my post got deleted, but i want to reason for the sake of my future improvements
post #2487338
post #2487332
post #2487348
The lineart on the first is pretty sketchy, but I don't see any anatomical flaws so I'm kind of surprised it wasn't approved
For the second, Nishizumi MIho's arm really seems to streeeetch around that neck
The third is a simple lineart, simple shading, and low-effort background post. Those go unapproved pretty often
nanami said:
post #2484529
post #2484960
post #2480861
post #2421686
The lineart is really pixelated on the first one.
The second one has trouble with the right arm (also, since so many approvers clicked "do not like" instead of just ignoring it, maybe they're getting tired of Megumin?)
On the third, there's something jarring about the arrangement of the different elements. (Maybe my eyes expect the innertube to swing away from her head when she jumps, instead of framing it?) Also her left arm seems a lot smaller than the right, and there's not enough of a space difference for it to just be perspective.
The fourth has some questionable anatomy around the chest in order to get more of the breast (singular) in view, but that's not usually enough to sink a post.
