Posted under Tags
post #1420459, post #1391692, post #1350736, post #1253821, post #1013891, post #800525, post #511632, post #381831, etc.
There are quite a few posts where a long-haired girl has only a short length of hair in twintails.
Also mentioned in the short_twintails wiki:
Characters with long hair can also wear short_twintails.
Updated
But that is classified as two_side_up and is erroneously tagged as short_twintails.
The long hair mentioned wearable as short twintails is most likely at shoulder length max, at which point it generally has been up to the tagger's discretion to tag for long_hair or not.
CodeKyuubi said:
The long hair mentioned wearable as short twintails is most likely at shoulder length max, at which point it generally has been up to the tagger's discretion to tag for long_hair or not.
For shoulder-length hair, it says to use neither long_hair nor short_hair.
Agree that the examples in Toks' list are more two_side_up, but still not sure about short_twintails -> short_hair. Is the length of hair tied up like that clear enough?
In previous discussions, there was resistance to making two_side_up separate from twintails (and likewise, one_side_up from side_ponytail). Would be good if we could finally form a consensus on that, rather than leaving it on a confusing not-separate but not-implicated middle ground.
I still think two_side_up should be separate from twintails, where twintails use the bulk of the hair while two_side_up uses only a small section. Look at Sasaki Chiho for clear examples of both.
Hillside_Moose said:
I still think two_side_up should be separate from twintails, where twintails use the bulk of the hair while two_side_up uses only a small section. Look at Sasaki Chiho for clear examples of both.
I agree. There are a lot of instances of two_side_up getting tagged twintails, so I'm at least wondering if it's acceptable to do cleanup, since in cases like Chiho's it would allow for easier searching of the "regular" twintails hairstyle. Similar case with Nibutani Shinka for one_side_up (post #1348951) vs. side_ponytail (post #1383658).
