I don't think we need Lycoris Recoil costume tags

BUR #53916 has been rejected.

nuke inoue_takina_(hawaii)
nuke nishikigi_chisato_(hawaii)

I noticed @Insanity_Demon made these tags (pinging to make you aware of this topic), and personally I don't think we need these tags.

Their kimono costumes (post #7364790) and their winter casual costumes (post #5626692) also get plenty of fanart, but they're still just variations of casual clothing. Nothing like gacha game costumes.

There's also no wikis or implication BURs for these tags but again, I don't think we need them.

BUR #53919 has been rejected.

create implication inoue_takina_(hawaii) -> inoue_takina
create implication nishikigi_chisato_(hawaii) -> nishikigi_chisato

I don't see what's the issue with making it easier to search for these costumes, especially when each one of them has around a hundred posts, which is more that can be said for a lot of already implied costume tags out there.

nsmrtmr1 said in forum #415222:

BUR #53919 has been rejected.

create implication inoue_takina_(hawaii) -> inoue_takina
create implication nishikigi_chisato_(hawaii) -> nishikigi_chisato

I don't see what's the issue with making it easier to search for these costumes, especially when each one of them has around a hundred posts, which is more that can be said for a lot of already implied costume tags out there.

(One of) the issue(s) is making costume tags for a bunch of casual outfits for a random anime that doesn't really need them because they're mostly just random outfits that are decently (but not perfectly, no) searchable with a handful of other tags.

If these are justified, we can make costume tags for the kimonos, the winter clothes, the blu-ray cover bikinis (post #5777715, rough search), why not the Lycoris Uniform as well then. Now you've ended up with between 6 and 10 new tags just for the main protagonists, not even mentioning side characters, that clutter tags and will require upkeep. I'm also not saying someone might make them, I'm saying there would be little reason not to make (and good reason to make) at least a few of these, if Lycoris Recoil is going the way of costume chartags anyway. Having 1 random costume set tagged while multiple other recognizable and common ones go untagged would be ridiculous.

Let me be the first to admit that I mainly did it as a test to see whether people thought it was worth doing or not. I'm now starting to realise that doing that unilaterally wasn't such a good idea, and even if the implications do get approved, I've already made a mental note to not be so impulsive in the future.

ANON_TOKYO said in forum #415247:

I'm also not saying someone might make them, I'm saying there would be little reason not to make (and good reason to make) at least a few of these, if Lycoris Recoil is going the way of costume chartags anyway. Having 1 random costume set tagged while multiple other recognizable and common ones go untagged would be ridiculous.

It's as if I've warned everyone about this. Even when you're dealing with costumetagging cases outside of the Costume Tagging Debate, things will always go towards it due to maximalists.

This bulk update request is pending automatic rejection in 5 days.

This bulk update request has been rejected because it was not approved within 45 days.

The bulk update request #53916 (forum #415216) has been rejected by @DanbooruBot.

This bulk update request has been rejected because it was not approved within 45 days.

The bulk update request #53919 (forum #415222) has been rejected by @DanbooruBot.

Bumping this in the hope it gets seen now that BURs are being handled again, I still don't think these tags serve much purpose.