How do I tag this?

Posted under Tags

Myth-of-Stars

Oxitofin said:

I went through the wiki page for bridget (guilty gear) and read through some forum discussions on the topic.
Seems like post #9713240 and post #9540522 should be tagged as "futanari 1girl" due to breasts being pretty prominent in the images.
Tried this out and they both got reverted. Are these incorrect?

There's probably someone better suited to address this topic than me, but both those posts have contradicting hashtags for your edits.
post #9713240 has no futanari tag on pixiv, and even if we ignore the pixiv tags and follow "tag what you see, not know" those nipples aren't big enough to be categorize as breasts with 100% certainty, puffy chest seems like the more suitable choice for this post.
Another thing to note is that Xipa is well-known to do futanari and futa with female artwork, so if they intended for Bridget to be a futa, then they would of definitely have put futanari on there.

post #9540522 says in it's pixiv hashtags itself that Bridget is a guy AND otoko no ko at that, though the post does have prominent breasts, it doesn't necessarily mean that Bridget is female in this picture and male with breasts covers this.

I tried messaging you this before, but judging by your post changes, you seem very fixated on correcting Bridget's gender on several posts.

Reply
tamuraakemi

People edit war those kind of posts all the time so basically the only thing you can hope for is that staff says something about what the tag should be.

I think relying on the absence of artist tags is pretty weak but I don't really desire to participate in an edit war today.

Reply
Myth-of-Stars

Can someone stop changing the tags on post #9713240 already? It's always the same thing with Bridget (Guilty Gear) posts tag-warring over what gender they are.
I know the wiki page states that Bridget (Guilty Gear) is male unless physical evidence proves otherwise, but that doesn't change the fact that people will have clashing opinions.
If there's even a hint of femininity, people keep assuming they are 1girl, even though it's completely possible they have puffy chest intead., and just because Xipa usually does futanari artwork, doesn't mean all their art is futanari.

Reply
wingdings

Myth-of-Stars said:

even though it's completely possible they have puffy chest intead

the definition of that tag seems to have been stretched to the point of comedy. i can count several posts that could just as well be tagged small, sometimes even medium breasts solely off the first few pages.

Reply
1 569 570 571 572 573 574 575 576 577 639