Posted under General
If possible, could an Approver please explain why these weren’t approved? Any feedback would be appreciated.
post #11639741
post #11639788
post #11639859
post #11639888
post #11639905
post #11639929
post #11639945
post #11639950
post #11639959
post #11639963
Feedback for this.
Can anyone provide feedback on the following posts? Myself and others frequently upload art from this artist and I've never had a deletion on their work before but 6 posts of their art from me have been deleted over the course of a couple of days. Just wondering if there's any issues with these, any and all feedback is appreciated.
post #11694630
post #11694641
post #11694662
post #11694754
post #11694614
post #11708439
Hello! I need feedback for these posts
pasandoelrato said in forum #453609:
Hello! I need feedback for these posts
Greetings and welcome! Taking a look at both of these pieces, I think the reason for their disapproval is that they're both considered "borderline." They are of a quality that you may see on the site, but you would definitely need to have someone who has an appreciation for Amy Rose to think that they are deserving of being kept. To provide a bit more detailed analysis, #11719837 has a bit of a strong Western art style that is reminiscent of cartoons. The line work is medium to heavy width, and the shapes that are being used are pretty blocky. Compare that to #11709591, which is a lot more varied in their line work and shape design. The problem that I'm seeing with it, is the colors and linework are almost too subtle, and it makes discerning the individual parts a bit difficult. To speak plainly, I am on the fence with #11709591, as I do like the design but the muddiness of the color strikes me as a bit odd. I'll mull on it.
That said, there are a number of different reviewers here, and the ones that saw it may not have had strong feelings that it was of a quality that they would want to maintain. There are quite a few approvers that have an appreciation for Sonic, so it may be possible that hitting "Appeal" would see these pieces approved.
--And that's also part of a the process of upload feedback, as in order to request feedback you need to go through both the initial posting and the appeal.
Good luck!
hiya! i'd like feedback on these...
argentb said in forum #453633:
Greetings and welcome! Taking a look at both of these pieces, I think the reason for their disapproval is that they're both considered "borderline." They are of a quality that you may see on the site, but you would definitely need to have someone who has an appreciation for Amy Rose to think that they are deserving of being kept. To provide a bit more detailed analysis, #11719837 has a bit of a strong Western art style that is reminiscent of cartoons. The line work is medium to heavy width, and the shapes that are being used are pretty blocky. Compare that to #11709591, which is a lot more varied in their line work and shape design. The problem that I'm seeing with it, is the colors and linework are almost too subtle, and it makes discerning the individual parts a bit difficult. To speak plainly, I am on the fence with #11709591, as I do like the design but the muddiness of the color strikes me as a bit odd. I'll mull on it.
That said, there are a number of different reviewers here, and the ones that saw it may not have had strong feelings that it was of a quality that they would want to maintain. There are quite a few approvers that have an appreciation for Sonic, so it may be possible that hitting "Appeal" would see these pieces approved.
--And that's also part of a the process of upload feedback, as in order to request feedback you need to go through both the initial posting and the appeal.
Good luck!
Thank you!!! I'll keep it in mind
post #11664859 comic
post #11669676 impressionism art
post #11690747 s
post #11696113 ak-12 meme
post #11696186 ak-12 meme
Callsign: Cedar conceptual art:
post #11709106
post #11709107
post #11709108
post #11709109
post #11709110
post #11722144 g36c
Hi! These are animations I made myself, and the second one got quite a decent score. But both of them got deleted nonetheless, so I'd greatly appreciate some feedback.
Thanks
Why was post #11730392 not accepted?
post #11701555
post #11706201post #11684536
It's been awhile, but I would like to know why these didn't go through? Would apricate some feedback on them
Updated by TheGamingRodent
Hello! Could someone please explain me and give feedbacks on why the works of this artist: https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts?tags=hcl_313xxx&z=1 keeps getting deleted? And also, the works by cashew-kun? For example: post #11671249 for example and also post #11728139 and post #11728151
Hello, could a moderator please explain why these posts were deleted? Is it simply that none were interested in the posts? Thank you!
I'd like to know why post #11714161 was deleted. I'm friends with the artist, and they're willing to improve the piece to meet the site's standards.
Some feedback would be appreciated
post #11711278
post #11711144
post #11729390
post #11711119
post #11706020
post #11619512
post #11619500
post #11729363
post #11568508
post #11625503
post #11729413
post #11619528
post #11729546
post #11734581
post #11737199
post #11619901
post #11619597
post #11423212
post #11619901
post #11679622
post #11570770
post #11570735
There are no issues with the quality—the anatomy is solid, and the animation is high-quality or effectively executed in a specific style.
I would like to know the specific reason why it is not being approved.
It seems these are being overlooked—are they not recommended? (I thought they were significant because they look different from the approved versions.)
I would like to verify this.
This is a revision submitted by the original poster; since the parent post has already been approved, this one should likely be approved as well.
The commentary implies the existence of a video.
It is unhelpful that it has ceased to exist simply because it was not approved.
Howdy. Tried to upload a comm a few days ago, could I get feedback on what was wrong?
post #11734827
I don't think any of these would even be considered "borderline" tbh. I can't say for sure.
post #11708381
post #11708237
post #11706686
post #11706362
post #11699448
post #11699443
post #11699437
Admittedly, these two are borderline.
post #11706562
post #11699358
Hey folks! I'm looking for feedback on two posts:
Is post #11736149 considered off-topic? I honestly thought this would've been one of the easier uploads to get through out of the bunch I uploaded, but I guess not haha.
And is post #11721050 a bit too much of a rough draft? I feel like despite that, it's still decent quality, but maybe not.
NSFW
post #11757833
post #11757797
post #11757780
SFW
post #11741322
post #11741294
I'm new to uploading on the site, I figured I'd try to start contributing art that I don't see uploaded instead of just leeching for downloads. However, I genuinely do not understand the submission queue system at all.
I can understand not wanting low quality work, but I don't get what the reason (disinterest) means, I marked the ones explicit as explicit appropriately and put as many tags as I could that I felt were applicable
mirakuruun said in forum #453834:
Unless the posts have already been deleted you shouldn't be posting them here, as posts that are pending are still in the queue. The queue system is as simple as 1 Approver needs to think a post is worth approving for it to be Active, and that's all. Don't get hung up on (disinterest) it's just the default disapproval reason.
