A sudden platinum upgrade raffle has appeared!

Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Posted under General

Shibi said in forum #445479:

Keep in mind that a quite a few approvers will see the post again when you appeal so "30 approvers" might actually be 18 or lower.
All of your posts by that artist are now approved, so the system is working as intended. Mods/owners approving instead of regular approvers don't affect the system.
It seems like you still have more relaxing to do.

Also, contributors skip the queue so they have no disinterest to deal with.

It’s not about “relaxing” it’s the clear disparity between so called “disinterest”. When the quality is no different but 98 hours pass and it’s apparently still lack of interest that calls to question the rating of approvers. It’s not that deep to call out.

Okay, so I am here to ask for feedback for post #11569075.
Besides,
1. I want to know what illustration is so called good enough?(Maybe I am just too bad to upload illustration here)
2. Is it possible for a single reviewer to reject multiple times?
3. By appealing, it is possible that almost the same set of reviewer reject the post for another 72 hours. Is it a good idea to appeal later (like after weeks or so). As the "deleted" post is not really deleted unless it is specifically taken down by moderator or admin, would I lost the right to appeal if I don't appeal immediately after being flagged.

BenningYaz said in forum #445540:

Okay, so I am here to ask for feedback for post #11569075.
Besides,
1. I want to know what illustration is so called good enough?(Maybe I am just too bad to upload illustration here)
2. Is it possible for a single reviewer to reject multiple times?
3. By appealing, it is possible that almost the same set of reviewer reject the post for another 72 hours. Is it a good idea to appeal later (like after weeks or so). As the "deleted" post is not really deleted unless it is specifically taken down by moderator or admin, would I lost the right to appeal if I don't appeal immediately after being flagged.

1. Not an approver, so won't comment on this. Your post is still pending though so it could still be approved.

2. Each reviewer can reject a post only once in the 3-day review period.

3. I feel it is better to appeal later. There is no time window after which you lose the right to appeal a post but you only get one appeal per post.

Onryo25 said in forum #445529:

[..]

When you reply like this, it's hard to believe that you're listening to what anyone is telling you even though you acknowledged that a reply was made. What happened to "I'll leave it at that"? You're way too focused on getting approvals but not understanding the spirit of the message. And as I told you before, you're complaining about approvals despite all of them eventually being approved.

When I said "relax", that didn't mean "relax it'll get approved before 3 days are up", it meant "relax, there is no point in getting agitated over it, just move onto something else, it may get approved/undeleted later". For some people this means "use the deletion to improve your standards on what to upload". For others this means appeal posts that you think are good enough to be active or just wait for another chance for it to be undeleted in the future like a deletions run (some approvers look through recently deleted posts and undelete some) or if a mod is checking if you're worth trusting with a promotion.

Posts are looked at mostly in isolation and approvers approve based on what they think is good enough to be on the site. Contributors are trusted in knowing what fits the site and have the privilege to upload posts directly to active status. In that regard, yes, there will obviously be things a contributor uploads that a non-contributor may be waiting a fair bit for. If approvers don't like the image enough to approve it, then don't take it personally - move on.

This topic is for requesting feedback from approvers to help improve your eye for quality. It's not a topic to complain about the modqueue working as intended or for "calling out" approvers who have different quality standards than you that a post may not meet. Any further replies that aren't asking for feedback will be deleted.

I am trying to upload 4 doujin pages that I commissioned an artists to make for me. These are the pages:
post #11549877
post #11549987
post #11550017
post #11550080

Because the artists (StormFedeR) has already posted these pages on his X (Twitter) account, I though it would be appropriate to re-post them here while also providing credit and the original link to his post. And again, I am the client who payed for the pages to be created. They are new works of art, though a sexual parody, and are not part of a paywall because they were publicly posted.

I ask, why would these works of art not get approved? I would like to know, because I have already done appeals for each of those posts and yet they were not approved. So, can anyone tell me why could these posts not get approved?

Inghwatc said in forum #445652:

post #11518353
post #11518504
post #11518559

I don't understand why these posts of mine above get deleted. Meanwhile a low quality comic gets approved:
post #11578311

Although I am just a member, from what I know, the so called "low quality comic" was uploaded by contributor. Contributor is authorized to upload directly without needing extra approval from any reviewer.

If you think post #11578311 is bad, you may flag it and send it to review.

Hey, I was wondering why my post (#11557117) for lunarloser' Power Girl (artist I also added) was deleted? I was sure I put in all the right tags and source for my first post and I think it's rather dismissive to do that.

I was unsure where to ask about this and didn’t want to make a new forum post about it. But this post got flagged for “anatomy check” post #11594524

Are we anatomy critiques now? Like let’s be real there are so many “inconsistent anatomy” artist to artists but now all of sudden it’s being flagged. Is this normal because I’ve never seen a flag for anatomy before.

1 738 739 740 741 742 743