Deletion appeal thread

Posted under General

This topic has been locked.

Please re-consider:

post #657263

Also, if possible, if this image is refused deletion appeal, would it be possible to tell me why since I don't upload unacceptable images again? I have been browsing this site for a while and am not sure why this image would be considered unacceptable, if appeal is refused.

CyberAkuma said:
Please re-consider:
post #657263

Please use the standard linking syntax, like so:
post #657263

Also, if possible, if this image is refused deletion appeal, would it be possible to tell me why since I don't upload unacceptable images again? I have been browsing this site for a while and am not sure why this image would be considered unacceptable, if appeal is refused.

It's a bit too low quality. The content itself is not objectionable, but it's not amazingly great either, and it just loses to the visible JPEG compression artefacts.

Appealing for post #656394
Reasons: part of an existing pool, already translated.

(Is it just me, or has a lot of stuff - Touhou at least, maybe others too - been getting pocket vetoed lately? In the Love Confessions pool over the last couple of weeks, one post was approved, two were by Contributors or higher, and twenty died for lack of approval, which is a way higher rate than normal...)

kounishin said:
(Is it just me, or has a lot of stuff - Touhou at least, maybe others too - been getting pocket vetoed lately? In the Love Confessions pool over the last couple of weeks, one post was approved, two were by Contributors or higher, and twenty died for lack of approval, which is a way higher rate than normal...)

Touhou love confessions are utter crap, and *all* of them, save for maybe two or three novel ones, should get purged. It's *way* below the proper rate of rejections for them, which should be around 99.99%.

Edit: Note also that the "part of an existing pool" reasoning holds only for sequential pools in which continuity is broken when you delete posts. For random themes such as love confessions or making whomever cry, the posts should still get judged on an individual basis.

Updated by 葉月

pyth0n said:
Utter crap you say? The artwork seemed to be about the same quality as a good deal of the other images I've seen here. Is it the context they're in?

A healthy majority is mediocre at the very best. And all of them, save for the ones explicitly parodying the concept, are just very pink fantasies with no basis in reality, made by people with zero writing skills.

葉月 said: A healthy majority is mediocre at the very best. And all of them, save for the ones explicitly parodying the concept, are just very pink fantasies with no basis in reality, made by people with zero writing skills.

I don't take the writing into account when judging them. Just the art. There are a lot of poor quality ones, but nowhere near "99.99%", even accounting for hyperbole.