Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

TheGamingRodent said:

post #10377876

Her lower half doesn't seem right. People likely took issues with her right leg looking too small or the left leg looking too long. Either way they don't look the same size which is the most glaring thing I see here.

TheGamingRodent said:

post #10382406

The waist, I'd say. Thighs feel like they're disconnected from her body at that angle. Her upper left arm seems too small too.

lotus_flame said:

post #10361146
why nobody likes it

I wouldn't be able to guess what the approvers think but my guess would be that maybe Jacinthe's face looks off to them here?

ADeshantis said:

Bunch of posts with heavy boob focus but no nipples if anyone's worried about content.

post #10386350
post #10386368
post #10386392
post #10386385
post #10386413

I can't help but think I've seen pictures with similar quality and similar sizes here so I'm wondering what the problem with these is, I can't see any of the artist's stuff on the site and they draw some pretty hot images. Is it because they're from a non web source? The guy put out a mega with all of his drawings on his Newgrounds and that's what I pulled from.

From what I've seen, posts like these aren't so likely to go through. Gigantic breasts posts feel like they're almost always from people who already hit contributor. For future reference though if the posts came from a mega link by the artist, I'd probably link that too. Idk if the staff would prefer you link the post from the artist on Newgrounds where he links the mega or if they'd prefer you'd link the mega itself in the source field. Whichever you link there, I'd probably put the other in the comments of the post just to be safe.

Two of my 4 uploads didnt get approved and got looked over would like to know why or if they are fine to send through appeal.

post #10383592
post #10383526

BigBara said:

Her lower half doesn't seem right. People likely took issues with her right leg looking too small or the left leg looking too long. Either way they don't look the same size which is the most glaring thing I see here.

The waist, I'd say. Thighs feel like they're disconnected from her body at that angle. Her upper left arm seems too small too.

I wouldn't be able to guess what the approvers think but my guess would be that maybe Jacinthe's face looks off to them here?

From what I've seen, posts like these aren't so likely to go through. Gigantic breasts posts feel like they're almost always from people who already hit contributor. For future reference though if the posts came from a mega link by the artist, I'd probably link that too. Idk if the staff would prefer you link the post from the artist on Newgrounds where he links the mega or if they'd prefer you'd link the mega itself in the source field. Whichever you link there, I'd probably put the other in the comments of the post just to be safe.

yeah, those might be legitimate reasons

Nacha said:

Not every approver checks this topic here and if users keep on sending way to many uploads at once, the possibility that they're ignored is higher. For us it's easier if people use their appeals.

Yes, approvers only approve uploads they personally like/think is of good quality. There is no other way for us to measure "good quality".

yeah, its really frustrating that they refuse to approve good fan art sometimes

NiceLittleDan said:

I generally think the quality across the board is low here to be perfectly honest. post #10162998 is probably the best out of this lot but the face is kinda flat and the outstretched hand isn't great.

post #10376435 is sourceless which turns approvers away.

I try to find the source but, sometimes the original source gets deleted and even tried using source nao. but even then still can't find the source

czernin said:

I said it a while back... SauceNao will work in this situation, just use the deleted one and bad pixiv ID/bad twitter ID tag. Also, not all of them are deleted because I did check and they had active links

I checked and they no longer have active links

SineFineBelli said:

I checked and they no longer have active links

If the link is gone you can still use it, please read what I said again. Just put the bad id tag of whichever site you got it from

SineFineBelli said:

Ok, thanks for the info. Actually I tried using saucenao, and sometimes even using saucenao doesn't work

yandex image reverse search, google reverse image, etc. try using those

SineFineBelli said:

yeah, its really frustrating that they refuse to approve good fan art sometimes

Honestly I find it strange how in settings to show deleted posts is off by default. (Maybe posts would be seen more as well as getting approved by others that way)
Also wouldn't getting more Approvers help, or am I just dumb for even suggesting it

frostwyrmn said:

Two of my 4 uploads didnt get approved and got looked over would like to know why or if they are fine to send through appeal.

post #10383592
post #10383526

The second one feels like it would normally go through. A bit surprised to see 13 approvers reject it. I tossed in an appeal for you on that. The first one idk, maybe the faces seemed off to them or the limbs might've seemed too thin.

SineFineBelli said:

I checked and they no longer have active links

Are you still finding links though? It's better to share something than nothing at all if possible.
Also, I recommend just editing your last post instead of quadruple posting. Multiple posts pushes the prior posts asking about deleted posts out of view.

Siknakaliux said:

Honestly I find it strange how in settings to show deleted posts is off by default. (Maybe posts would be seen more as well as getting approved by others that way)
Also wouldn't getting more Approvers help, or am I just dumb for even suggesting it

Approvers generally know how that works so I don't think changing the default would affect that, but it is possible I guess that other users might see a decent deleted post and would at least toss an appeal more often.
I think, particularly last month, we were feeling the shortage of approvers. I had a number of posts where only like, maybe 6 approvers saw the post and they were all either within the first few hours of the post going up or on the third day.

post #10396907 been a few days but i think this is worth approving

BigBara said:
I think, particularly last month, we were feeling the shortage of approvers. I had a number of posts where only like, maybe 6 approvers saw the post and they were all either within the first few hours of the post going up or on the third day.

A smaller queue due to promotions might help with this problem. I'm not against more approvers if someone is qualified but I don't believe it to have been the issue

Siknakaliux said:

Honestly I find it strange how in settings to show deleted posts is off by default. (Maybe posts would be seen more as well as getting approved by others that way)
Also wouldn't getting more Approvers help, or am I just dumb for even suggesting it

Yeah, I think approvers are way too apathetic, and refuse to approve good fan art. But I agree with you on the deleted feature hiding deleted posts

NiceLittleDan said:

A smaller queue due to promotions might help with this problem. I'm not against more approvers if someone is qualified but I don't believe it to have been the issue

I respectfully disagree with your opinion, there needs to be more approvers

Siknakaliux said:

yandex image reverse search, google reverse image, etc. try using those

Yeah, I try using those too, but sometimes even that doesn’t work

BigBara said:

The second one feels like it would normally go through. A bit surprised to see 13 approvers reject it. I tossed in an appeal for you on that. The first one idk, maybe the faces seemed off to them or the limbs might've seemed too thin.

Are you still finding links though? It's better to share something than nothing at all if possible.
Also, I recommend just editing your last post instead of quadruple posting. Multiple posts pushes the prior posts asking about deleted posts out of view.

Approvers generally know how that works so I don't think changing the default would affect that, but it is possible I guess that other users might see a decent deleted post and would at least toss an appeal more often.
I think, particularly last month, we were feeling the shortage of approvers. I had a number of posts where only like, maybe 6 approvers saw the post and they were all either within the first few hours of the post going up or on the third day.

Yeah, there is just not enough approvers

@SineFineBelli Please read this part of BigBara's post again.

BigBara said:

Also, I recommend just editing your last post instead of quadruple posting. Multiple posts pushes the prior posts asking about deleted posts out of view.

BigBara said:

The second one feels like it would normally go through. A bit surprised to see 13 approvers reject it. I tossed in an appeal for you on that. The first one idk, maybe the faces seemed off to them or the limbs might've seemed too thin.

Are you still finding links though? It's better to share something than nothing at all if possible.
Also, I recommend just editing your last post instead of quadruple posting. Multiple posts pushes the prior posts asking about deleted posts out of view.

Approvers generally know how that works so I don't think changing the default would affect that, but it is possible I guess that other users might see a decent deleted post and would at least toss an appeal more often.
I think, particularly last month, we were feeling the shortage of approvers. I had a number of posts where only like, maybe 6 approvers saw the post and they were all either within the first few hours of the post going up or on the third day.

Ok, I’ll try to

post #10347932

Would like to have opinion on why posts like these aren't approved when other works of more or less the same quality do get approved.
Princess Knight (nagasawa tougo):
post #10232828
post #10232860
Clalaclan (utomo): post #10378295
Arknights (oni tengu):
post #8250477
post #8260106
Group picture of OCs (matteok): post #10136123