You think it's that bad? I wouldn't have accepted it if it looked like chicken scratch like the other two, but this one at least seems artistically sound to me.
Posted under General
This topic has been locked.
Well, post #624590 itself isn't so bad, but particularly I didn't like the way you said "if post #458018 is approvable, and post #574061 approvable by two mods". That's almost like saying "we approve crap already, so let's have some more".
True the logic is fallacious; I just felt like pointing out things that are more or less in the same vein but worse (in my opinion) which had been approved whereas this one hadn't been.
I also felt they deserved mention exactly because I was approving this, despite having resisted those posts' approval.
I approved it because I thought it was acceptable in and of itself, not simply because it was better than the worst thing approved.
Soljashy said: Well, post #624590 itself isn't so bad, but particularly I didn't like the way you said "if post #458018 is approvable, and post #574061 approvable by two mods". That's almost like saying "we approve crap already, so let's have some more".
Yeah. post #624590 is okay but let's please never ever use those other two infamous posts as justification for anything.
Thanks.
Please reconsider this. It is quite important...
post #573889 Part of pool #1111