Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Posted under General

Log

vivoleko01 said:

post #2194144

fossilnix said:

Her clothes and skin look like they're made of the same glossy material (poor shading), and the rips are really unnatural. Her left hand looks weird and her lower legs look really short compared to her thighs (like the artist was trying to foreshorten and failed; also notice how one thigh is longer and skinnier than the other). There's a giant bulge between her left shoulder and breast. Finally, something seems really off about her position (how far over her butt is swung); but maybe that's just from looking at her too long.

Additionally, that's not how butts work she shouldn't have two melons protruding from her pelvis.

Reply
Pianist

vivoleko01 said:

post #2198571
post #2199900
post #2199901
post #2199902

Those are just from Custom Maid 3D or whatever, with the bad that that implies - particularly, the models aren't the best, and their poses are really stiff and awkward (this is most noticeable on the last one). The composition of each shot is nothing to write home about either.

post #2199619
post #2201814

These two... are better than the first four, I'd say, but still poorly-drawn. The first is kind of cute, but the lineart is shaky at certain points, and the shading is either too simplistic or done through gradients (which is a huge no).

While the second is better about those things, the anatomy is worse, even considering that it's supposed to look cartoony like the source material - the light brown-haired dude's face is too big for the size of his head, the blonde girl's arms are too thin, etc.

Though I imagine that this artist is just inexperienced, and will get better as they practice.

Reply
tapnek

The first one's a bit confusing as to the how her torso and legs match up as to how they are turned. This is especially a problem with seeing the crossed legs. The art is also something left to be desired. As for the second one, it just doesn't look anime or Japanese-copyright related but I would approve of it if I could.

Reply
tapnek

The first one looks like she lacks a torso, the second one has questionable perspective problems, and the fifth one is not really that well drawn to begin with. Wo there looks like a midget. The third and fourth ones really aren't that bad, to be honest, aside from the Courtesan's nose and her short arms.

Reply
BrokenEagle98

@MaxAndEmilytate
The third and the fourth posts are both explicit, and explicit uploads have a much higher deletion rate than the other categories. I ran some numbers from the month of January 2016, and the following are deletion rates I calculated:

  • Explicit: 282 deleted / 2412 total = 11% deletion rate
  • Questionable: 168 deleted / 3920 total = 4% deletion rate
  • Safe: 573 deleted / 23984 total = 2% deletion rate

This isn't to say that you can't upload explicit posts... it's just that they are less likely to be approved.

Reply
MaxAndEmilytate

BrokenEagle98 said:

@MaxAndEmilytate
The third and the fourth posts are both explicit, and explicit uploads have a much higher deletion rate than the other categories. I ran some numbers from the month of January 2016, and the following are deletion rates I calculated:

  • Explicit: 282 deleted / 2412 total = 11% deletion rate
  • Questionable: 168 deleted / 3920 total = 4% deletion rate
  • Safe: 573 deleted / 23984 total = 2% deletion rate

This isn't to say that you can't upload explicit posts... it's just that they are less likely to be approved.

Huh, didn't know that particular statistic. Any idea why?

Reply
Saduharta

MaxAndEmilytate said:

Huh, didn't know that particular statistic. Any idea why?

The basic way I understand it is that explicit work tends to less likely be from official artwork and/or professional artists. A few reasons that tie together with the ones after:

1) Non-hentai works have a much larger economy; IE making a living drawing non-hentai art is much easier as a full time artistm

2) Non-hentai works have many more venues and sites they can be displayed and sold at.

3) There are less laws, regulations, and rules regarding the distribution, purchasing, and display of non-hentai work.

4) Lastly, there is a larger general audience because of those reasons, tying back in to number 1.

So it all adds up to the fact that professionals' artwork is more likely to be safe or fanservice, making the explicit stuff more likely to be amatuer. Oh, and small note about fetishes; A smaller audience means more willingness to take chances or appeal to niches. So you are more likely to get hentai with unpopular, controvertial, or uncomfortable material. Which just makes it less likely to be approved.

Reply
1 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 718