D 🙏

How is this even a question?
- disgusting
- American Psycho but female
- secretly an eldritch nightmare
- affluent, curvy woman with refined tastes

D, hands down.

I considered B, too, for a moment, but I then saw the camera and noped out there.

Arcana55 said in comment #2588461:
- American Psycho but female

No, that's a pornographer. Batewoman would have had plastic covers everywhere.

- secretly an eldritch nightmare

I too disapprove of transsexualism.

- affluent, curvy woman with refined tastes

Considering the competition, D seems suspiciously like the obvious pick. I don't trust it and I'm sure her adult Wednesday Addams looks are some sort of reference.
All in all, I'd probably just ask A for a clean STD test, to take a bath and come over to my place. The redhead slob doesn't hide what she is and probably doesn't have any ulterior motives or (significant) dark secrets. And admittedly, I'd probably have more in common with her than D.