Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

jxh2154 said:

People have been asking for a thread where feedback on uploads could be obtained. So here it is. I have some reservations about how acrimonious this thread is likely to get, and if it turns into nothing more than a flame-fest, I will lock it.

Rules for those requesting feedback:
#1 - You are not guaranteed feedback. It is entirely voluntary to give it.
#2 - Danbooru may simply not be an appropriate place for your favorite art. If so, accept this and move on.
#3 - Try not to be too thin-skinned,and don't take things personally.

Rules for those giving feedback:
#1 - Give constructive feedback only.
#2 - Refrain from name-calling. Asking people to be thick-skinned doesn't mean you're allowed to be insulting.

I don't know if they can delete posts by request, but i want this one deleted
post #7369813

undelete this > pool #21492 , post #7347509 , post #7304712 & post #7283864 , post #7281583 & post #7119413

godgun42 said:

Far as the pool goes, please read comment on post #7054951.

Vanniaa067 said:

I don't know if they can delete posts by request, but i want this one deleted
post #7369813

Manually deleting posts before three days is reserved for rule breaking posts and each deletion fills five of your upload slots for the three days. Just wait until it gets approved or automatically deleted.

Just posted some commissions I had done by an artist but they weren't approved. Two people apparently felt the art was low quality? In terms of resolution it is high definition (and at least I don't feel they are low quality). Don't know what I did wrong if there is anything I can improve.
post #7364307 and the rest of the family of post

A bit curious for post #7350047

The color, expression, and theme are all really solid.

LarianPiug said:

Just posted some commissions I had done by an artist but they weren't approved. Two people apparently felt the art was low quality? In terms of resolution it is high definition (and at least I don't feel they are low quality). Don't know what I did wrong if there is anything I can improve.
post #7364307 and the rest of the family of post

Seems ok to me.

argentb said:

A bit curious for post #7350047

The color, expression, and theme are all really solid.

I liked. Exotic

So first time posting: Post #7366631, Post #7366651, Post #7366723, and Post #7366736.
All of them have 1~3 approvers saying the reason was 'poor quality' despite the posts having absurdres tag on it? I assume that the two are not correlated?
As this was my first time posting, I randomly chose an artist I liked, saw that it had rather few entries, and decided to upload the art to test the waters. Half of it had netorare by chance (not something I specifically went out of my way to choose, I simply like the art-style); should I stick with something vanilla next time?
Is there anything I can do better next time?
Just looking for some clarification.
Please and thank you.

Can anyone give feedback:
post #7362358
post #7362747
post #7362365
post #7365949
post #7361487
post #7355012

Howmanytriesdoineed said:

Low quality usually doesn't refer to image resolution. Rather low effort on artist's side.

post #7364957 Reason for removal?

Hello, could you please review this post again, keep in mind that only eight approvers checked this:
post #6726786

Hello. I think my post post #7369238 deserves to be approved because I didn't find any technical issues. Please review and give it a chance.

I am interested in why my most recent posts (Not the gaza one, I'm aware of the flame war) have been getting removed.

But I'm more interested as to why I have a pending rating of 5/9 despite me not having anything pending or in appeals rn.

ZixZax said:

Hello. I think my post post #7369238 deserves to be approved because I didn't find any technical issues. Please review and give it a chance.

They probably don't like the weird resolution on it. Ryu seems out of proportion compared to those of the right side of the pic

Giga_Skunk said:

But I'm more interested as to why I have a pending rating of 5/9 despite me not having anything pending or in appeals rn.

Posts that were manually deleted consume 5 upload slots. They will be restored when the three-day queue period of that post expires, if I'm not mistaken.

post #7357167
post #7352572
post #7105172
post #7037489
post #7024070
post #6990145
post #6914911
post #6914845
post #6787019
post #6786335

WinDGo said:

post #7352572 It's technically a lowres crop of the original image, but I approved it and created a tag for the character;
post #7105172 It's slightly better than the child, but what's this source? I'm not familiar with it;
post #7024070 Personally I'm not here for 3D models;
post #6914911 post #6914845 I see no reason to post both. I looked at official art and they're simply comprised of tachi-e images put together in a low effort (post #7085460, asset #19881059). You posted other images with the same sprites, which makes them low quality posts for me, I'd only approve the tachi-e;
post #6787019 post #6786335 They're from a trustful source, but both are cropped duplicates of the scans.

Ubaldo_the_Uploader said:

Posts that were manually deleted consume 5 upload slots. They will be restored when the three-day queue period of that post expires, if I'm not mistaken.

I had this before the most recent post though.

Why was that *manually* deleted though? Couldn’t be because of the comments alone