Shared bathing rename and potential implication

BUR #20315 has been rejected.

remove alias shared_bathtub -> shared_bathing
create alias shared_bathing -> same-sex_bathing
remove alias shared_bathing -> same-sex_bathing
create alias mixed_bathing -> mixed-sex_bathing
remove alias mixed_bathing -> mixed-sex_bathing

"Shared bathing" is a confusing tag name for specifically baths shared between characters of the same gender. If anything, the name makes it sound more like the tag is for any kind of bath with 2+ people participating, regardless of the participants' gender.

Additionally removing the shared_bathtub alias on the same principle. I think keeping "coed_bathing" for mixed-sex bathing is fine - while the idea of a bath being "coeducational" is silly, it's a common way to refer to something mixed-sex.

BUR #20316 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

remove alias shared_bathtub -> shared_bathing
create alias shared_bathing -> same-sex_bathing
remove alias shared_bathing -> same-sex_bathing
create alias mixed_bathing -> mixed-sex_bathing
remove alias mixed_bathing -> mixed-sex_bathing

Second variant of the BUR that additionally turns shared_bathing into an umbrella tag for all shared baths.

The bulk update request #20315 (forum #256140) has been rejected by @nonamethanks.

The bulk update request #20316 (forum #256141) has been approved by @nonamethanks.

BUR #21131 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

create implication same-sex_bathing -> shared_bathing
create implication mixed-sex_bathing -> shared_bathing

Had to split this from the previous BUR due to validation errors.

The bulk update request #21131 (forum #259659) has been approved by @nonamethanks.

BUR #21132 has been rejected.

create implication shared_bathing -> bathing

Missing implication. Unless things like showering mixed-sex_bathing don't count.

Edit: moved to topic #25559.

The bulk update request #21132 (forum #259662) has been rejected by @nonamethanks.

mixed-sex_bathing and same-sex_bathing wikis probably need stronger clarification.
Under the current definitions, it is not exactly clear - at least to me - if, for example 1girl 2boys shared_bathing should be tagged both, neither, or only one of those.

Somehow we've ended up with mixed-sex bathing implicating same-sex bathing, which I imagine wasn't the intent.

blindVigil said:

Somehow we've ended up with mixed-sex bathing implicating same-sex bathing, which I imagine wasn't the intent.

Man, no idea how that even happened. I'll fix it.

BUR #21135 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

remove implication mixed-sex_bathing -> same-sex_bathing
create implication mixed-sex_bathing -> shared_bathing
create implication same-sex_bathing -> shared_bathing

-

It's because BUR 20316 didn't remove the shared bathing -> same-sex bathing alias like it was supposed to.

The bulk update request #21135 (forum #259691) has been approved by @nonamethanks.

Post versions are gonna take a while to catch up, I'll cook up a script to fix the mistags once it's done.

Mistags should be fixed now.

hdk5 said:

mixed-sex_bathing and same-sex_bathing wikis probably need stronger clarification.
Under the current definitions, it is not exactly clear - at least to me - if, for example 1girl 2boys shared_bathing should be tagged both, neither, or only one of those.

I'd say same-sex means exclusively same-sex. I'll amend the wiki.

[“Shared bathing” is a confusing tag name for specifically baths shared between characters of the same gender. If anything, the name makes it sound more like the tag is for any kind of bath with 2+ people participating]

That is EXACTLY what shared bathing is “2+ people participating”, regardless of the circumstance of the same or of different gender; while mixed_bathing is a varient of the “2+ people participating” tag, just used exclusively when its participants of different genders.

shared bathing = 2+ people of either the same gender and/or of different genders participating

mixed_bathing = 2+ people of different genders participating

its not at all confusing. just need an implication:

mixed_bathing → shared_bathing

for filtering search results to work as intended in this scenario.

tadams587 said:

[“Shared bathing” is a confusing tag name for specifically baths shared between characters of the same gender. If anything, the name makes it sound more like the tag is for any kind of bath with 2+ people participating]

That is EXACTLY what shared bathing is “2+ people participating”, regardless of the circumstance of the same or of different gender; while mixed_bathing is a varient of the “2+ people participating” tag, just used exclusively when its participants of different genders.

shared bathing = 2+ people of either the same gender and/or of different genders participating

mixed_bathing = 2+ people of different genders participating

its not at all confusing. just need an implication:

mixed_bathing → shared_bathing

for filtering search results to work as intended in this scenario.

You're half a year late, we already fixed these tags.