DocAstaroth said: Someone who throws away his life has no right to complain, if someone else picks it up. In my opinion.
This guy is totally right. Throwing your life away is saying that you're worthless. If someone else decide to give you some value by saving you, then you don't have any right to complain.
The thing is that she didn't pick her life back up, her mind is not in a state that she is in debted to her. She is thinking that her life was robbed and she can't do anything about it.
aListers said: Why should somebody else decide how long you suffer for though? If somebody doesn't want to suffer any longer shouldn't they get the decision to quit?
That's exactly it. "Someone who throws away his life has no right to complain, if someone else picks it up." You defied their will. You took away their right and freedom to choose whether or not to live. What gives you that right? What gives you the right to say your decision is better then theirs?
Shinkukage09 said: That's exactly it. "Someone who throws away his life has no right to complain, if someone else picks it up." You defied their will. You took away their right and freedom to choose whether or not to live. What gives you that right? What gives you the right to say your decision is better then theirs?
Considering that self-destruction often involves traumatizing those around you, I'd say its within their right to prevent it. Humans are social by nature, for the most part, if someone we care about is collapsing, getting involved to prevent it, even if it means overstepping that person's free will, is the correct choice.
Free Will, while beautiful and what not, has limits to when it can be exercised. The issue is not in its violation but for what reasons it is violated.
It should be stated that anyone who is in the state of mind necessary to seriously contemplate, or attempt, suicide, is not in the right state of mind to make proper decisions for themselves at that point.
In the end, you went ahead without asking for my opinion, and suddenly you're bringing me to the doctor for a check up?Have you become god or something?I was prevented from dying, and here I am, sick because of you.Seriously..., you're too self-seeking.Huh...? It's not too late...I'm saying, you're pursuing your own interest.Huh...? What am I?You steal my freedom to live or die, and my freedom to act for myself.What am I to you?Who the hell do you think you are?