What SHOULD have happened in the show.

And then everything was right with the world forever.

And there was much rejoicing.

I'd would make Madoka Puella a much happier show...

RedEyesAssassin said:
I'd would make Madoka Puella a much happier show...

But would it be so memorable as it is then?

"Holy Crap, the monster just ate our cute magical familiar! And I still haven't become a Magical Girl! O.O Ohcrapohcrapohcrap!"

Or something?

And nothing of value was lost.

Perfect Ending :3

ignatius2722 said:
But would it be so memorable as it is then?

The familiar being eaten before the heroine can become a magical girl is plenty memorable. How, you ask? Because now the girl's sense of justice demands she do something even without magic. Cue the normal people becoming badass and fighting magical girl villains instead of being useless and sitting on the sidelines.

Comartemis said:
The familiar being eaten before the heroine can become a magical girl is plenty memorable. How, you ask? Because now the girl's sense of justice demands she do something even without magic. Cue the normal people becoming badass and fighting magical girl villains instead of being useless and sitting on the sidelines.

You. Are. A. Genius!

Basilikos said:
And nothing of value was lost.

Indeed, because immediately after this Kyubey reformed and proceeded to not give a fuck.

He was a bit disappointed Charlotte ate his remains herself, though.

Comartemis said:

The familiar being eaten before the heroine can become a magical girl is plenty memorable. How, you ask? Because now the girl's sense of justice demands she do something even without magic. Cue the normal people becoming badass and fighting magical girl villains instead of being useless and sitting on the sidelines.

Or the normal people getting nom-nom'd themselves, but not before pissing themselves thinking of the why-mes and the what-ifs.

Perfectly possible. Be glad Kyubey can reform and essentially force the poor girl into delayed witchdom, yes?