A bit late on this Neko keyhole trend =p (Razz)

Iv'e been drawing a lot of catgirls lately

At first, i wanted to do simple shading, but out of habit I ended up detailing it a lot. Im stuck between which shading style looks better. I like detail a bit more but it's very time consuming. 
I took screenshots between two types shading while I was drawing. They weren't finished at that point in time, but I think the difference is still obvious enough.
Please tell me which type of shading you like better. Comparison in the link bellow.

sta.sh/01h30jg1obnd