saitama and superman (dc comics and 2 more) drawn by wizyakuza

Artist's commentary

  • Original
    •

    who's gonna win?

    www.wizyakuza.com/collections/anime

    www.etsy.com/listing/253808160/one-punch-man-vs-superman-anime-dc?ref=shop_home_active_1

  • Comments
  • Recommended
    •
    redmanx73
    [hidden]

    This fight would either never end, or somehow end in a draw. Both Superman's and Saitama's strength- according to canon- have no limit... but even then, Superman's strength is tied to the sun and he has a definite weakness in Kryptonite, whereas Saitama is a physical god without those limitations.

    1 Reply
    Selvokaz
    [hidden]

    redmanx73 said:

    This fight would either never end, or somehow end in a draw. Both Superman's and Saitama's strength- according to canon- have no limit... but even then, Superman's strength is tied to the sun and he has a definite weakness in Kryptonite, whereas Saitama is a physical god without those limitations.

    None of that really matters, because Superman has defeated Gods of Strength, and Power before, the thing is Saitama like many many many MANY shonen heroes is that they don't have any real rules in place for themselves, at least nothing that would come close to measurable, or they make up their laws of physics and other scientific facts we would normally hold accountable in order to measure and understand how certain powers they do work... where as Superman after 60+ years has been continuously rewritten over and over in order to make more and more sense of his abilities and that in and of itself both gives him limitations as well as some ridiculous boundaries within those limitations.

    If Saitama could even keep up with Superman I'd be surprised.. this is a guy who can travel hundreds Lightyears in a few moments, and hear distress calls from Earth in the void of Space where we know sound doesn't normally travel. If there is a god within Saitama, and it has a name, it's name is Kal-El.

    1 Reply
    Winson
    [hidden]

    redmanx73 said:

    This fight would either never end, or somehow end in a draw. Both Superman's and Saitama's strength- according to canon- have no limit... but even then, Superman's strength is tied to the sun and he has a definite weakness in Kryptonite, whereas Saitama is a physical god without those limitations.

    Superman can easily recharge and superchange his strength and has a healing factor of some sort.

    Saitama doesn't have a healing factor, can't fly, and can't breathe in space.

    1 Reply
    Marcokotaro
    [hidden]

    Winson said:

    Superman can easily recharge and superchange his strength and has a healing factor of some sort.

    Saitama doesn't have a healing factor, can't fly, and can't breathe in space.

    Saitama dosen't need a healing factor since no one can hurt him (and since no one has hurt him, who nows if he really dosen't have na unused healing fator?), can jump and rum as fast as he needs to, and, as seem before, isn't damaged by the vacum of space. Not that superman would have a chance to bring the fight to space anyway.
    And yes, they both have no limit, that's their thing, but, unlike Saitama, Superman is not invincible.
    Don't get me wrong, I love superman, but you can't compare a comedy character to a serious one, Saitama wins by default.
    That said, this Picture is awesome regardless.

    1 Reply
    OmniGman
    [hidden]

    lavitzlover said:

    This is the modern superman so saitama could beat him easy.

    The so-called "modern" Superman can:

    1. Hold up the weight of the entire Earth for seven days without getting tired (this happened in "The New 52" so it's as recent as Superman gets).

    2. Shrugged off a supernova from a star that was five times the size of our solar system's sun.

    3. Fought for hundreds of years in an alternate dimension against an unending army of demons (remember, magic is supposed to be one of his weaknesses, or, rather, he's not invulnerable to it).

    4. Used his heat vision to reignite the Earth's molten core in seconds after it had been cooled solid.

    5. Fought his way out of the inside of a black hole.

    The last four feats happened just a few years before "The New 52" reboot.

    Trust me, I love Onepunch Man a hell of a lot more than I do Superman, but Saitama isn't quite at that level yet. Give him time, and maybe by the time his series ends this will be a real fight, but for now Superman pretty much laughs off everything Saitama can throw at him.

    Only way this could possibly end with Saitama one-shotting him is if we used animated Superman or maybe the newest movie Superman.

    2 Reply
    azurelorochi
    [hidden]

    OmniGman said:

    Stuffs

    Except I don't think Saitama's power is a matter of strength. You can see that many characters DID indeed survive being punched by him, most notably all the human characters. Saitama simply had never killed a single human(at least while they are still 100% human), yet he is shown to have difficulties in holding back his power from killing non-human foes in 1 punch(save for a few).

    So if we're trying to apply logic to this supposed joke scenario, I'd say Saitama's power just decide by magic or whatever to exert as much power as needed to incapacitate an enemy. It's only a matter that different enemies may never be incapacitated unless entirely killed, that's why Saitama's punch will kill space gods but not humans.

    Still not gonna vote neither for or against if he could win against Clark though.

    0 Reply
    P.Suzuki
    [hidden]

    Ascoat said:

    Yep, nailed it. To give Saitama a real challenge, pit him against Squirrel Girl.

    SQUIRREL GIRL: Nice try Mr. Saitama, but the real "Caped Baldy" would be mad if I fought you, just because you said you were him.

    SAITAMA: But I AM "Caped Baldy"! It's just a stupid super hero name they gave me!

    1 Reply