Danbooru

Ratings check thread

Posted under General

Does post #2897704 warrant a Q rating? There are plenty of images depicting characters in bikinis, showing far more skin, that are rated safe. Perhaps the uploader is just being cautious - which isn't a bad thing at all - but I'm just wondering if Q isn't a bit much.

Kyuzeth said:

Does post #2897704 warrant a Q rating? There are plenty of images depicting characters in bikinis, showing far more skin, that are rated safe. Perhaps the uploader is just being cautious - which isn't a bad thing at all - but I'm just wondering if Q isn't a bit much.

Yeah, that's safe. It seems to me that he's being a bit too cautious, as he rated post #2894181 and post #2821366 as Q, among others. Someone should go through user:TomReidem rating:q to see if there's others - it looks to me as if there's quite a bit in need of fixing.

ion288 said:

Please unlock and change these to S:

Done

Not as sure about these:

I'm not sure about some of those either, specifically
post #2463067 (cameltoe)
post #2463203 (nipple tweaking)
post #2006871 (not exactly a tasteful pantyshot)

The others are done.

Shouldnt cum make these E?

I think the line of thought here is "how can you tell it's cum and not just some random fluid?"
Personally I'd tag them as E because it's pretty obvious to me, but @BrokenEagle98 probably has a better opinion on the matter, as he was the one who changed them to Q.

Does this object insertion make this E?
post #2462932

Yeah this looks very explicit to me, even more so because as per previous discussion visible object insertion was judged to be E.

nonamethanks said:

I'm not sure about some of those either, specifically
post #2463067 (cameltoe)
post #2463203 (nipple tweaking)
post #2006871 (not exactly a tasteful pantyshot)

The first one not only has cameltoe but you can see her nipples and areolae through her top. For the second one, you can see the nipples the girl is tweaking there. I'll give you the third one, though. I would rate it safe since it lacks details like cameltoe but similar posts have been rated Questionable.

nonamethanks said:

Personally I'd tag them as E because it's pretty obvious to me, but @BrokenEagle98 probably has a better opinion on the matter, as he was the one who changed them to Q.

Yeah, that was part of a bulk revert of user #490655 who got banned for rating vandalism. I didn't go through the posts manually, and instead just applied the undo action to all of that users edits.

ion288 said:

post #469256 is locked to S. Should it be S?

No, it should be questionable.

ion288 said:

On a similar vein, post #883683 has huge nipples on that monster. Do we rate monster nipples Q? Other examples on non human tits are post #1454054 and post #666786. Should they be Safe?

The first one doesn't look like it has breasts with nipples unless you really look into it since its a non-humanoid monster. The rest are Questionable since they involve humanoid characters with exposed breasts.

1 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 57