Hello, some of my post are getting deleted, I need feedback please.
post #8377853
post #8377296
post #8378091
post #8378125
post #8383038
post #8378097
post #8378099
post #8378116
Posted under General
Hello, some of my post are getting deleted, I need feedback please.
post #8377853
post #8377296
post #8378091
post #8378125
post #8383038
post #8378097
post #8378099
post #8378116
not mine but still
post #8372688
post #8368268
Hi, any feedback on why this post wasn't approved? Please give a second chance.
post #6189533
Updated by SidBarrett
I feel like there are way too few approvers to look around during a certain timezone. When things were in the queue for even longer than 12 hours, chance of it getting approved after that will get lower over time. If you are lucky, some approvers might see your uploads right when they were dropped.
post #8371376
What's wrong with this?
aimuahanhk said:
Also these
post #8379796
post #8379791
post #8379788
post #8356239
post #8356038
If I were to guess then for the first two it's the image quality. I could be wrong but they just look like either you or the artist cropped them down to individual images. As for the main image, I think it's just not getting lucky with approvers given this artist has had other works similar be approved.
The Nino image has a couple things weird about it, the left arm and feet to me being that. Might be anatomically incorrect in other areas but I'm not well aversed in anatomy.
The last image might be the gradual change in standard. The artist hasn't had anything new approved in two years. It can be argued that this is a lower quality than usual work from them too.
I understand that art is subjective, not everyone can like everything I do and that's fair. But, I don't understand why that means it cannot be on the site as a non-deleted post? A score of 34 and 35 favourites isn't *massive* sure, I understand a lot more people maybe saw the art and didn't click on it or other reasons, but to say that this post isn't worth putting on the booru because 6 people *didn't* like it feels a bit strange, idk.
Again, those 6 approvers are 100% entitled to not like the art, just is a bit odd to me that because of that they decide the art can't be viewed without the status:deleted, especially since it was liked by a small crowd I guess.
Checked only 4 times
post #8382908
post #8386234
post #8369144 (only 4 times on appeal)
I don't mind deletions, got plenty of them anyway, but when the pictures are not even checked you wonder what is the point of the queue.
This place would be even worse without ion288 so at least I want to thank to them.
japooter said:
I understand that art is subjective, not everyone can like everything I do and that's fair. But, I don't understand why that means it cannot be on the site as a non-deleted post? A score of 34 and 35 favourites isn't *massive* sure, I understand a lot more people maybe saw the art and didn't click on it or other reasons, but to say that this post isn't worth putting on the booru because 6 people *didn't* like it feels a bit strange, idk.
Again, those 6 approvers are 100% entitled to not like the art, just is a bit odd to me that because of that they decide the art can't be viewed without the status:deleted, especially since it was liked by a small crowd I guess.
The score and number of favorites have no bearing on whether a post is approved. NSFW posts tend to be liked/favorites a lot regardless of quality.
Bernkastel83 said:
The score and number of favorites have no bearing on whether a post is approved. NSFW posts tend to be liked/favorites a lot regardless of quality.
I'm aware and I'm sorry if I come across as egotistic with that, but it just slightly surprises me I guess that of all the approvers, all of them disliked it.
japooter said:
Again, those 6 approvers are 100% entitled to not like the art, just is a bit odd to me that because of that they decide the art can't be viewed without the status:deleted, especially since it was liked by a small crowd I guess.
Six Approvers is not a lot. If you think the art quality is good enough, you can try appealing it in hopes that other Approvers will see it.
Updated by FemboyWoody
The official artworks of vtubers' outfits are good to have as a reference for tagging, so I don't really see why this wasn't approved. Was it due to my tagging or some other reason?
I cannot fathom what is wrong with this one from a routinely approved artist.
This can stay removed if approvers genuinely do not like it a lot, but the other two images from this set that I have uploaded were in-fact approved after an appeal from someone else, so I am wondering if there is in fact a different reason or it was just different approvers seeing this one and so a different outcome?
Also post #8392329 and its children are all part of an artist that tends to get disapproved a lot (same artist as my previous post here too, their art style remains pretty consistent). I want to give this artist attention, but it's a shame as it seems approvers usually do not gel with it. If anyone of those approvers could explain why, I can happily upload stuff that might hit their standards, for now I will stop uploading stuff of theirs as clearly it isn't that popular among the higher-ups.