Danbooru

Question about TOS regarding breast size.

Posted under General

I just read forum #28997

it seems that people are against any post with gigantic_breasts on it. I understand enforcing the ToS, but are there not exceptions? is post #481790 grotesque?

Like I said in the other post, the artist for post #481790 is using the proportions for contrasting the two characters, and the breasts are not the focus. I could also see an artist using these proportions for comical purposes.

I agree that most gigantic_breasts would most probably fall under "grotesque" and that most of the current ones should probably be deleted, but should have an absolutist rule about this?

There aren't any gigantic_breasts posts I personally care for, but I just don't think this is the appropriate way to go about things

Updated

sgcdonmai said:
gigantic breasts are against the ToS

I don't come to that conclusion from reading the ToS or the Wiki.

"It should be noted that breasts about this size are candidates for deletion under Danbooru's Terms of Service ("grotesque"). Tread cautiously when uploading pics that deserve this tag."

it's saying "posts with gigantic_breasts TEND to be grotesque and are CANDIDATES for deletion, so be careful when uploading them"

it's not the same as "Do NOT upload ANYTHING with gigantic_breasts, because gigantic_breasts=grotesque"

in post #481790 the artist was drawing a god. Gods are usually drawn with either really delicate features or really strong features. The artist decided to draw her with really strong features, that's why the breasts are of that size. I know this is only one post, but I'm saying that there are exceptions

also, how can post #614487 survive while post #489898 (which doesn't fall under the "at least two heads of size" category) is deleted? was it just because it was (incorrectly) tagged with gigantic_breasts? There aren't that many gigantic_breasts posts anyway, I think we can use our common sense to judge each individual post.

And please don't be confused, I do not want to keep most of these posts here. But I think that banning gigantic_breasts completely would be potentially discriminating against quality art which happened to have gigantic_breasts in it in a non-grotesque manner.

Updated

1