Danbooru

Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Posted under General

zerouter said:

Any specific reason why my post not got approved as fast as *ehmm, posts with more flesh attractions on it?

No offense here.

post #2945528

One reason is, as Log said, Danbooru is not my primary focus. Many things go on in our lives besides this site, like finals this week...

Another. Often as I go through the queue I will leave certain posts I kind of like but have reasons to question them, or they're like 50/50 and I have to weigh whether I approve and will go back to them over the next few days. Sometimes when you put off making a decision the queue does for you by just deleting it after the 4 days.

The post you linked is one such post. I considered approving it a few times and did not. So understand when something is in the queue many eyes will fall upon it, sometimes multiple times.

freecom said:

post #2949705
post #2949708
post #2949719
post #2949730
post #2949732

i get the feeling i already know what answer to expect (most other dungeon_and_fighter official_art pieces are full body, and this character doesn't seem to have any of that yet, having been revealed less than a week ago), but i'd figure i'd post anyway just to make sure.

It's good art, but male-only images have a specific niche, so it's generally always a risk to upload them unless you have unlimited upload privileges.

nanami said:

post #2944077
post #2943162 (part of a series)
post #2942552
post #2938415
post #2931880

1. Something seems mediocre about the first one, not feeling well enough to examine it closely.
2. Looks fine
3. Groin a little long and right leg is misplaced and short to fit it in the frame
4. Looks okay for most part, not too bad and not too good, though hand sizes are not even and are over-rendered with thick lineart (which increases contrast and draws the eye)
5. Lacking in proper directional shading for the most part, considering she's out in the sun, but is appealing look-wise.

CodeKyuubi said:

It's good art, but male-only images have a specific niche, so it's generally always a risk to upload them unless you have unlimited upload privileges.

haha, well that explains the lack of fan art for the male DFO classes on this site. thanks for the feedback.

edit: it looks like someone's gone and approved them anyway even after getting deleted. whoever that was, thanks for that.

Updated

Well, it was suggested to me I should visit this thread, so why not give it a try. I have been wondering why these uploads were deleted:

post #2819040
post #2819042
post #2819046
post #2819061
post #2819062

Those five pictures are part of a set, the first five of which were approved for good reason as I think. It's fanart of a great quality and notable for the shading specially, imho. I've seen worse get approved. The artist seems reasonably popular and has a lot of other works uploaded here because of his consistent quality output. There is precedent for a set of his with lots and lots of minor variations being fully approved. These pictures are on topic too, as the subject matter is a girl from an anime/manga. This is why I'm not really sure what to make of the deletion. I recently wanted to upload a new picture from this artist but before I even try I would like to have a better grasp on what went wrong last time.

Eroppelion said:

Well, it was suggested to me I should visit this thread, so why not give it a try. I have been wondering why these uploads were deleted:

post #2819040
post #2819042
post #2819046
post #2819061
post #2819062

Those five pictures are part of a set, the first five of which were approved for good reason as I think. It's fanart of a great quality and notable for the shading specially, imho. I've seen worse get approved. The artist seems reasonably popular and has a lot of other works uploaded here because of his consistent quality output. There is precedent for a set of his with lots and lots of minor variations being fully approved. These pictures are on topic too, as the subject matter is a girl from an anime/manga. This is why I'm not really sure what to make of the deletion. I recently wanted to upload a new picture from this artist but before I even try I would like to have a better grasp on what went wrong last time.

I think the problem could be explained best with post #2819061 but all five have the same problems.
She appears to have no ribcage which causes that the area above her midriff looks cut off from her lower body.

There are a lot of posts here

nanami said:

post #2947423 Cant help you here.

post #2936957 Deformed left hand, shoddy background, abnormally thick thighs. Is she covered in lube?

post #2929308 There are a few anatomical oddities. Her neck seems to be overly long as are her fingers. Her right arm is crocked above the elbow. I dont think these are deal breakers though. Mostly its just a rather unremarkable image like thousands others.

kudus said:

post #2950644 This could have been approved. Blondie has a wonky right hand (how is she holding that?) and her neck seems to be to far back, could just bee perspective though. Overall quality is in the lower range for whats usually approved.

Sarangpata said:

post #2952117 Mediocre quality. Grayscale is obviously less popular than colour.

post #2952118 Same as above. Contrary to popular belief cum pics are less likely to be approved.

post #2945076
post #2945077 Cant help you here. Something looks odd with the testes/dick.

Ho boy. Il try to answer these but please dont ask for this many at the same time again. Also you can simply write post #2936690 instead of copping the entire address.

yn said:

post #2936690 This is not a good scan wit some artifacts. The composition isnt very interesting and the block of text to the left also subtracts from the artistic quality.

post #2934336 Nothing really wrong with this but there are thousands of smiling girls on Danbooru and this one doesnt stand out in any way. Line art and clothes could be better.

post #2946991 I would have approved this one If I could. Male solo arent that popular with the mods though.

post #2953502 Character profiles arent that popular. Cant really help you beyond that.

post #2953516 There is a lot of clutter and text and not much art here. Danbooru is all about the art.

post #2953530 Same as the one above. The images are lowres.

post #2949384 Cant really help you here.

post #2949436 Multiple problems with this one including colouring, shading, anatomy (shoulders) and the rather small size. This is considered inferior quality.

post #2952728 Is this some kind of mix between an oekaki and a "regular" image? All that text and the poorly drawn chibi really subtracts from the impression and it would be a rather mediocre image even without that. Also bad hands.

post #2952744 Same as above though not as bad.

post #2879992 Solo male. Not very interesting.

post #2851570 Really bland image. Girls torso looks odd and the blurring around the edges doesnt really work.

post #2819174 A bit tricky to answer here. Her left arm looks abnormally thin and she is holding the sword in a rather odd way. I want to say something about her head size/position but Im not sure whats up there.

"A lot of my posts tend to get deleted." Dont let this discourage you but try to learn what is appreciated/accepted and what isnt. Asking here is a good first step. Look at what other images get approved and what isnt by searching status:pending and status:deleted.

I really don't see why any of these pics failed to get approved. The Astolfo one is of somewhat middling quality, but I don't think it's not enough to not get approved. "Grayscale is obviously less popular than colour." -ok, but why should that be a barrier? "Contrary to popular belief cum pics are less likely to be approved." -What's actually wrong with it though?

A number of my posts that haven't been approved are male focused, non-otoko no ko images, but I'm annoyed at how often they get no approval, and your reasons outlined really don't make much sense.

Also, I've never really understood why these posts got deleted:

post #2623173
post #2623177
post #2623175
post #2623179
post #2424896

The first 4 are of identical quality to the parent image, and of identical quality to countless other approved images from the same artist. I mentioned this in a previous appeal post, but no response. The last is a doujin cover, and there's many on this site.

Updated

post #2961428

There was no reason this post should have been deleted. Aside from being higher quality, if post #2893573 gets approved and all child posts, there's no reason this one should have been rejected. I've had a number of other male focused images of atleast decent quality that have been rejected (and have never been undeleted despite multiple appeals), and it kind of seems like it's become more common in general. I get that this site's audience is predominantly straight and otoko_no_ko images are the ones that mainly get traction, but I feel like a lot of moderators are judging posts purely on their own tastes and not basic quality.

1 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 365