Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Another batch of failed appeals. Most of these are definitely on the lower end of the quality scale, or I know in retrospect are low quality and am only appealing to exhaust all my chances with them; I don't expect anything to happen because of this post though. This also would have been the last batch of appeals of non-Momiji posts, but with the current raffle that might change. (The Momiji posts will go out in a batch of their own.)

SFW
post #8701603 - pixel art
post #8920348 - doodle
post #8488494 - I still don't know how I missed the weird eyes before
post #8500895 - Crop of a larger post
post #9178851 - This is the cover image for a side-story comic book associated with the comic in the pool it's in. All the other ones have been approved. Thanks!
post #9060922 / post #9060923 - The first two strips from the new comic by the author of the previous one. Their "full" non-chibi style is very hit or miss and this requires translation, so I probably won't be uploading more of it.

Questionable
post #8889304 - This artist's usual style
post #9113855 - Adding this in too; there was feedback "Big hands, and the breasts are a bit weird. For me personally, it's almost good enough, but not quite".

Thanks again!

post #9243125
post #9243306
post #9243298

Metalhead33 said:

post #9255265

Art from this artist has been nearly consistently approved.

Questionable ratings:
post #7441823
post #7441824
Uploaded a year back. Not sure if there's anything particularly wrong with them. Plus, these two are the only deleted ones from the same artist.

Why were these unapproved?

post #9191449
post #9222466
post #9225461
post #9234596
post #9259477

Hey! I've had a few posts deleted in the past, and for most of them I understand why. But I don't understand why these were deleted:

post #6054710 (uploaded and deleted a while back)
post #9257807 (uploaded and deleted recently, and it's what pushed me to ask in this forum)

The second one is especially confusing, since it was viewed by 8 approvers, and I believe it's a pretty good quality post, and it was still deleted.
I'd like to think that I'm always pretty thorough in my tagging when I upload as well.
Any feedback?

post #9245576
post #9231052 (parent post got approved)
post #8863780 (twitter version post #9105669 got approved)
post #9019855
post #8406941 (Twitter version post #6233760 got approved)
Please give another look and reply.

Hi, any feedback on why this post wasn't approved? Please give it a second chance.
post #9215002

Anything wrong with my upload with post #9220060 ? I'll change anything that it needs for it to be ok'd! Also one of the tags is character request, the character is mine named Holo (my name is usually Argorrath but I like making different names cos lol). Should the character request be there?

Thank you!

post #9022115
post #9022030
post #9020864
post #9161392
post #8615548
whats wrong with these

post #9179942
approved parent post #9123612

Anything on these? I've tagged them the best I could
post #9213347
post #9213138
post #9209489
post #9220868
post #6717661

ArdenianSun said:

Anything wrong with my upload with post #9220060 ? I'll change anything that it needs for it to be ok'd! Also one of the tags is character request, the character is mine named Holo (my name is usually Argorrath but I like making different names cos lol). Should the character request be there?

Thank you!

You can create a chartag for your OC, especially if you plan to post more of her in the future. Just type in char:[NAME]_(ARTIST) in the tag box. You can remove character request afterward.

Also, if you commissioned this, it should be tagged with commissioner upload.

Note than none of this will actually make it more likely for your post to be approved.

Blank_User said:

You can create a chartag for your OC, especially if you plan to post more of her in the future. Just type in char:[NAME]_(ARTIST) in the tag box. You can remove character request afterward.

Also, if you commissioned this, it should be tagged with commissioner upload.

Note than none of this will actually make it more likely for your post to be approved.

Oh ok I didn't know, thank you!! Will do that!

MF144 said:

Why were these unapproved?

post #9191449
post #9222466
post #9225461
post #9234596
post #9259477

For the first one, because her anatomy on her thigh is bad. Her right thigh doesn't line up with her hip where it should. Also, the line art is jagged.
The second, her eyes aren't facing in the same direction (one looking upwards, one down) and something is going wrong with the shoulders and breasts that I'm having trouble articulating right now.
Number 3, the shading is blocky, the features are simplistic, and perhaps this is just something I dislike but nothing is really happening in the image. I know that's common, but it's one way an image could win back some likability that this image doesn't have.
That's all I have time for right now.

andlabs said:

Another batch of failed appeals. Most of these are definitely on the lower end of the quality scale, or I know in retrospect are low quality and am only appealing to exhaust all my chances with them; I don't expect anything to happen because of this post though. This also would have been the last batch of appeals of non-Momiji posts, but with the current raffle that might change. (The Momiji posts will go out in a batch of their own.)

SFW
post #8701603 - pixel art
post #8920348 - doodle
post #8488494 - I still don't know how I missed the weird eyes before
post #8500895 - Crop of a larger post
post #9178851 - This is the cover image for a side-story comic book associated with the comic in the pool it's in. All the other ones have been approved.
post #9060922 / post #9060923 - The first two strips from the new comic by the author of the previous one. Their "full" non-chibi style is very hit or miss and this requires translation, so I probably won't be uploading more of it.

Questionable
post #8889304 - This artist's usual style
post #9113855 - Adding this in too; there was feedback "Big hands, and the breasts are a bit weird. For me personally, it's almost good enough, but not quite".

Thanks again!

If you already know in hindsight they aren't good, what are you asking for us to tell you?

CrossbowArcanePlus said:

If you already know in hindsight they aren't good, what are you asking for us to tell you?

Why are you giving advice on the art quality when you’re not an Approver?

post #9269172
post #9269123
post #9269036
post #9253304
post #9253283
Feedback pls?

About this post post #9218058 please help, I'm absolutely confused.
It got rejected for weird perspective. There are nothing indicating the POV and the smartphone belong to the same person and the anatomy is sound. Not to mention official art.

Blank_User said:

Why are you giving advice on the art quality when you’re not an Approver?

Do you have to be an approver to give feedback on art? I don't see why you would have to be, and there's nothing about that in the opening post.
The uploader will need an eye for art to stop getting rejected, and they aren't approvers either.