Danbooru

Tag alias/implication discussion

Posted under General

This topic has been locked.

LaC said: (*Not meant to start a reform:*)
I always thought singular would have made more sense.

I did at first too, but quickly decided I didn't care a lot either way. Consistency is what matters to me.

The problem is we have it both ways, we have sword -> swords and guns -> gun. If there was a preexisting consensus or consistancy, I'd say go with it, but there isn't one.

I believe this was discussed before, but nothing came of it. My suggestion would be to use the singular form unless it's a tag that comes in a natural pair (panties, etc).

Tsukasa said: integra -> integra_hellsing
The first name-only tag is fine as it is, but I think we should alias this for consistency's sake.

We try to avoid single name -> full name aliases. It's entirely possible that we'll need an "integra" tag at some point for something that has nothing to do with Integra Hellsing.

For now I'd say to just update the tags manually, rather than alias. It looks like there are very few.

There is another Integra in Solty Rei. We don't seem to have any images of her, but since they both have full names Integra alone is still ambiguous and should definitely not be aliased.

Correction: we do have two under integra martel.

Anyone with mass edit want to do integra+hellsing > integra_hellsing+hellsing?

Updated

wanchan said:
There is another Integra in Solty Rei. We don't seem to have any images of her, but since they both have full names Integra alone is still ambiguous and should definitely not be aliased.

Correction: we do have two under integra martel.

Anyone with mass edit want to do integra+hellsing > integra_hellsing+hellsing?

Done.

memegui said:
What's with the hifen in tengen_toppa_gurren-lagann?

The hifen (sic) seems to be used on the show's Japanese site as well as on Gainax's where the title is romanized. The hyphen seems to be absent on Bandai's English page however. I'm not too familiar with the series, so I don't know which would be more correct.

I was wondering...why is there a panties_around_one_leg tag?
IMO panty_pull already covers this (even the description say so).
I suggest this:

Delete alias /paol -> panties_around_one_leg

Add /paol -> panty_pull
panties_around_one_leg -> panty_pull

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 14