I totally agree with OOZ662. Superior plane doesn't determine victory in a dogfight, it helps but superior pilot skills will determine the outcome
I concur. Although, if all other things are equal... The Mustang has the edge here (slightly), as long as they aren't hit in the bottom...
However, the artist depicted this as an either way image. The Parent image is the other way around (this image lacks the damage to the FW190 that that image has and vice-versa with the P51).