By the description of the genderswap tag, all pics of female Ranma would apply, regardless of whether this gender-switching happens in the show or not.
sgcdonmai said:
By the description of the genderswap tag, all pics of female Ranma would apply, regardless of whether this gender-switching happens in the show or not.
sgcdonmai said:
Even more of a reason to keep the genderswap tags intact for Ranma's female form.
Yet several of the pictures of Naruko that are tagged genderswap are of Naruto under the effect of the technique, which, as you say, is an illusion. Genderswap is not a tag describing images of characters depicted as a gender they never actually become in canon. It's a tag describing a (or the ultimate effect of) the magical or magical-esque change of a character's gender. If you look under the genderswap tag wiki entry, it specifically mentions Ranma, among others, as a genderswap.
Saying that Ranma-chan shouldn't be tagged with genderswap because it's a canon genderswap is like saying that Bridget shouldn't be tagged with trap because he's canonically a trap. I think this is the third time in less than 24 hours that someone has made this mistake.
Also, sorry for the double post, but why not just make it so ranma-chan images automatically get genderswap too? Or is it considered a bad idea to have too many auto-tags going around?
Ranma ACTUALLY genderswap, and is a dual persona, not some deus ex machina that genderswap, and being how hes kinda like the creator of genderswappin' I think its good like this
Agreed, though it's not really a dual persona, is it? I mean, the whole point and appeal of Ranma-chan is that she has the same personality as male Ranma. If she went all moe and typically female (for an anime) it'd be pretty shit.
Before commenting, read the how to comment guide.
Cinnabar Gate
4 months agoMore Ranma-chan's don't have the genderswap tag and this is actually a form that Ranma has in the show so I'm pulling the tag from Ranma-chan images.
sgcdonmai
4 months agoBy the description of the genderswap tag, all pics of female Ranma would apply, regardless of whether this gender-switching happens in the show or not.
Precedent: The naruko tag.
Re-adding tags to all pics of female Ranma now.
RiderFan
4 months agoNaruto never actually becomes a biological female in the manga. It is only an illusion. Ranma does become 100% female.
sgcdonmai
4 months agoEven more of a reason to keep the genderswap tags intact for Ranma's female form.
Ffion
4 months ago"hey lets pull the genderswap tag from a character that actually genderswaps good idea right???"
no shut up
Eld
4 months ago+1
Yet several of the pictures of Naruko that are tagged genderswap are of Naruto under the effect of the technique, which, as you say, is an illusion. Genderswap is not a tag describing images of characters depicted as a gender they never actually become in canon. It's a tag describing a (or the ultimate effect of) the magical or magical-esque change of a character's gender. If you look under the genderswap tag wiki entry, it specifically mentions Ranma, among others, as a genderswap.
Teclo
4 months agoSaying that Ranma-chan shouldn't be tagged with genderswap because it's a canon genderswap is like saying that Bridget shouldn't be tagged with trap because he's canonically a trap. I think this is the third time in less than 24 hours that someone has made this mistake.
Teclo
4 months agoAlso, sorry for the double post, but why not just make it so ranma-chan images automatically get genderswap too? Or is it considered a bad idea to have too many auto-tags going around?
lolin86
4 months agoRanma ACTUALLY genderswap, and is a dual persona, not some deus ex machina that genderswap, and being how hes kinda like the creator of genderswappin' I think its good like this
Teclo
4 months agoAgreed, though it's not really a dual persona, is it? I mean, the whole point and appeal of Ranma-chan is that she has the same personality as male Ranma. If she went all moe and typically female (for an anime) it'd be pretty shit.
Adverso
4 months agoI love Ranma's expression under the last panel. So "WTF?"