Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

There's nothing wrong with these images post #2943580 post #2940707 post #2940079 post #2938374 post #2940074 so that they would not be accepted in this filthy shitole, beyond these ridiculous double standards based on fanboying and hate which have been adopted by the retarded moderators of this filthy shitole, especially when shit like these post #2943580 post #2942351 post #2940914 post #2936937 post #2932559 post #2927679 post #2923385 were easily accepted at the time of posting, meh!

I feel sorry for some of the people attending these English-language anime websites… Awwww…. they’re like little kids with their lollipops being taken away from them. Getting angry because someone likes something they dislike, hating fictional shows/characters which don't satisfy his stupid sense of wish-fulfillment, accusing other people from being clones, boogeymans, multiple accounts and other shit just because they like a character and/or a series they dislike, not to mention that they literally can't deal and accept the fact that there are people who like a character and/or a series they dislike, besides being fully obsessed with the stupid idea that if they hate something, then everyone hates him too.

It is obvious it would not be too different at a shitole that makes money at the expense of other people's work, where most of the moderators are hypocrite redditors and retarded fanboys of a childish wish-fulfillment mobage for loser otaku self-insertion called FGO who never made a drawing during their entire life and assess the fanarts based on personal preference/tastes such as fanboying and hatred, not to mention these retarded assessments with a double standard that it doesn't make any sense. You guys are a bunch of lowlifes, idiots, immature brats that doesn’t know anything but to hate fictional shows and characters which don't satisfy his stupid sense of wish-fulfillment, besides accusing other people from being boogeymans, clones, multiple accounts and other shit just because they like a character and/or a series you guys dislike. People like you guys disgust me. Jeez, so much negativity and childishness. Get a life!

shipforce said:

blah blah blah cry cry cry

You apparently never cared enough to check that a lot of the posts you linked as 'trash' were 'accepted' because they were uploaded by people who were deemed competent enough to bypass the approval queue. Apocrypha is already one of the less popular Fate series because of how under-represented they are in FGO, not to mention that the protagonist Sieg is even within his own copyright considered a weak character of little value other than to move the story along (So I've been told). Your blind obsession with him is admirable, but uploading him without being able to bypass the queue was a fool's gambit, just like uploading male-only or yaoi pics.

So you come onto the forum, rant immaturely about others being immature, complain about wish-fulfillment while worshipping a character whose very embodiment is wish-fulfillment, and then get banned because you never had the patience and foresight to actually listen to what others were saying, ignoring the posts that got approved and only doubling down on what didn't and insisting that you're right and everyone else is wrong. Sounds like a narcissist to me.

post #2940363
I'm kinda curious why this post got deleted, especially considering the number of favourites it got. Is it because of the shitty compression? Because other than that the face I'm making at the mods is the same as flan's.

Opask said:

post #2940363
I'm kinda curious why this post got deleted, especially considering the number of favourites it got. Is it because of the shitty compression? Because other than that the face I'm making at the mods is the same as flan's.

The anatomy looks kind of wonky to me. I can't really put a finger on it, but it feels like the torso might be too long and bent unnaturally to show the boobs, and the baggy hoodie hiding the body's curves doesn't help much either.

Opask said:

post #2940363
I'm kinda curious why this post got deleted, especially considering the number of favourites it got. Is it because of the shitty compression? Because other than that the face I'm making at the mods is the same as flan's.

Poor anatomy and coloring. That’s some serious back/spine issues she’s got going on there.

Also, favcount doesn’t say that much. If you check some of the users that favorited the post, you’ll notice that some favorite almost everything. The score is 12 at the moment. The 90th percentile score for te_toga is 21. The 90th percentile score for flandre_scarlet is 17. For touhou it is 15.

Approvers don’t look at favcount or score and are only supposed to go by post quality. Otherwise, only posts from popular copyrights would get approved and less popular copyrights and original works would all go unapproved.

kittey said:

Poor anatomy and coloring. That’s some serious back/spine issues she’s got going on there.

Also, favcount doesn’t say that much. If you check some of the users that favorited the post, you’ll notice that some favorite almost everything. The score is 12 at the moment. The 90th percentile score for te_toga is 21. The 90th percentile score for flandre_scarlet is 17. For touhou it is 15.

I guess I can see it for the poor anatomy. Though I would argue that this anatomy is probably better then some of the other recently uploaded things under the bad anatomy tag.

Also I didn't know that there was a way to view 90th percentile score, is that a builders feature?

Opask said:

I guess I can see it for the poor anatomy. Though I would argue that this anatomy is probably better then some of the other recently uploaded things under the bad anatomy tag.

“There are worse posts” is never an acceptable argument and that has been mentioned multiple times in this thread. If you see worse posts that have nothing else to save them, consider flagging them.

Also I didn't know that there was a way to view 90th percentile score, is that a builders feature?

No, I programmed that myself. Platinum/builder level database timeouts are required to calculate the score for large tags, but even then it’s not enough for tags with more than 600k posts.

Opask said:

Though I would argue that this anatomy is probably better then some of the other recently uploaded things under the bad anatomy tag.

@Opask
That is not an argument. Every post is judged on its own merits.
If you still think a post is "worse", then flag it: howto:flag.

post #2927703

T34/38 said:

post #2927703

Mostly bad hands/feet (especially for the right girl's hand applicable).
Genitals don't really make much sense. They should be testicles (I assume), but they look pretty poorly drawn.
Left girl's right leg from our view is probably detached from her body.

T34/38 said:

post #2927703

Poor lineart applied with just as poor shading and coloring.. The breasts on right char are just two semicircles with some smaller circles and fake shine. They almost look like part of a :3. The shoddy linework and hacked up depth on that alone is microcosm for everything else bad in the image, not to mention but mentioned anyway bad anatomy (look at that waist) and "cum" work.

BTW, did anyone check on my last batch? I've had no response since posting my list.

nanami said:

post #2857383
post #2866250
post #2849618
post #2873753
post #2901647

1. Head looks kind of weird.
2. Looks kind of like an amalgam of traces, torso looks strange.
3. Mostly good except for huge clown feet.
4. Looks pretty average, nothing too out of place or terrible.
5. Face proportions bonkers. Looks like those memes where it's 10% face and 90% head.

Hi. Is my first post here so I am not sure if this is the right place.
Well I planned submit this picture:
http://thumbs.hentai-foundry.com/thumb.php?pid=550920&size=600

But it was rejected. Is it so bad? XD. Or maybe I failed on something with tags?

Thanks for your time

Eldelbar said:

Hi. Is my first post here so I am not sure if this is the right place.

Yes, you made it to the right place to request feedback.

Well I planned submit this picture:
http://thumbs.hentai-foundry.com/thumb.php?pid=550920&size=600

But it was rejected. Is it so bad? XD.

“Planned”? But you already did... Also, you should link to Danbooru posts like so: post #2940982
Linking to an off-site image, a thumbnail at that, isn’t very helpful.

Anyway, it’s pretty mediocre and generally not what we want. I see two main issues.

• Anatomy and/or perspective are questionable. This is often a contentious issue because both are important to many approvers but many users either don’t see the problems or disregard them if something else in the image appeals to them. The back and especially the shoulder area look weird. The dress and right arm obscuring much doesn’t help either. Probably due to the puffy sleeves, the left arm looks broken. I can guess where it’s going, but it still looks like it has two joints.
• This kind of coloring isn’t very appreciated here. It doesn’t follow a consistent light source and everything looks like matte plastic, especially the skin. It looks more like a vinyl figure than a living being.

There’s also no background or anything else noteworthy to save the image.

Or maybe I failed on something with tags?

It’s not too bad for a first upload. There’s no source, which should always be added, and the tags no and sideboob don’t apply. Read a tag’s wiki article before using it.

Any specific reason why my post not got approved as fast as *ehmm, posts with more flesh attractions on it?

No offense here.

post #2945528

zerouter said:

Any specific reason why my post not got approved as fast as *ehmm, posts with more flesh attractions on it?

No offense here.

post #2945528

You can link to posts like this: post #2945528
Posts that have strong western influence despite being about eastern copyrights are pretty dangerous to upload if you don't have unrestricted privileges, even if they're just parodies of that kind. I personally think that post's fine and I've uploaded similar stuff before, but I'd strongly suggest you to just stick to "normal" posts unless you're 100% certain something like that is going to get approved.

nonamethanks said:

You can link to posts like this: post #2945528
Posts that have strong western influence despite being about eastern copyrights are pretty dangerous to upload if you don't have unrestricted privileges, even if they're just parodies of that kind. I personally think that post's fine and I've uploaded similar stuff before, but I'd strongly suggest you to just stick to "normal" posts unless you're 100% certain something like that is going to get approved.

What are you saying is that, I might be sued by the artist or the copyright holder for uploading this ?

zerouter said:

What are you saying is that, I might be sued by the artist or the copyright holder for uploading this ?

What?
No, he means that this post has a pretty unique artstyle. Meaning most Approvers on this site will likely skip it.

Don't fret about the amount of time that passes between a post being uploaded and approved. Not every approver sits on the site going through the queue every 5 minutes to ensure everything they like is approved immediately. They get approved when that person has time to go through the queue.