When should Fine_art be used?

A discussion on the discord arose so I'm opening a thread to discuss current use of fine_art.

Wiki states that "This tag is for actual fine art - that is, art created before the internet and digital art were a thing." Mostly containing paintings from the greats such as post #4314715 or post #250658

A smaller subset in the tag though contain paintings such as this one post #7138216 which are redrawn and recognizable, but not in a parodic sense as to warrant fine_art_parody.

Another smaller subset contains insets of classic paintings which have not been redrawn post #7097771 post #4292243 post #4917416.

I believe the second set of redrawn paintings are fine just leaving the painting copyright tag and calling it a day, but what about the third set here? Is this fine_art? Someone proposed fine_art_inset which I enjoy if these don't fall under the wider fine_art tag.

I'm fine with fine_art_inset being created, with stuff like post #7138216 also falling under it; and actual fine_art tag being reserved for actual 100% old stuff.

In topic #25353 I got the suggestion to include these in borrowed_inset, but I didn't do anything about it.

Thank you for taking the time to respond! I've tagged the images in that pool and in the fine art tag woth borrowed_inset for now. Consequently though I didnt tag any of the completely redrawn images with it since at that point they arent insets correct? Im also unsure if post #4292243 or post #6279253 cound as insets. Any thoughts?

The mention of fine art parody reminds me of the past discussion that tag has caused, i.e. forum #152108.

zetsubousensei said:

Thank you for taking the time to respond! I've tagged the images in that pool and in the fine art tag woth borrowed_inset for now. Consequently though I didnt tag any of the completely redrawn images with it since at that point they arent insets correct? Im also unsure if post #4292243 or post #6279253 cound as insets. Any thoughts?

I think post #6279253 is ok as game screenshot background, though the background is probably post #2497539 instead of a screenshot of the visual novel. I'd say post #4292243 is an inset.