More clarification on error tag - more tags?

Sometimes I see posts with error that don't look like they really need it.

Couple examples - post #509606, post #496096 (arms are a little thin but perspective makes it acceptable... to me at least). I'm sure there are lots more.

Proposing adding at least a couple more tags than just bad_anatomy (which is hardly used). Perhaps something like error_feet (for 2 left/right feet, more/less than 5 toes), error_hands (for the same on hands) at minimum, then more if needed? At least this way, I can see the error tag and then know where the problem is.

I think if someone is going to tag error they should leave a post explaining why, especially in cases like those.

Akari said:
Perhaps something like error_feet (for 2 left/right feet, more/less than 5 toes), error_hands (for the same on hands) at minimum, then more if needed?

bad_hands and bad_feet already covers this, I think.

Fencedude said:
I think if someone is going to tag error they should leave a post explaining why, especially in cases like those.

This. I really hate it when people add the error tag and leave no indication as to what the error actually is, especially when the error isn't immediately obvious. Even the wiki on error states this.

I think bad_hands and bad_feet are more for poorly drawn appendages, rather than erroneous ones. I suppose they could be combined, but it seems like they should be kept separate.

I do wish people would leave comments when they tag error, but at least an extra tag would replace that. Basically, it's one or the other.

Comments should definitely accompany error tagging. I can't even begin to figure out what prompted error on the Strike Witches image. Unless it was added for the "Rynette" engrish.

jxh2154 said:
Unless it was added for the "Rynette" engrish.

Which would be covered by engrish and/or typo.

The underused wrong_hand & wrong_feet are for the "two left feet" syndrome. More or less fingers/toes than normal is a tougher fit for that tag, though there's the (also rarely used) polydactyly for excess digits.

Updated the wiki, please do the same if you can think of any more tags that are sub-classes of error.

Out if pure curiosity, I must enquire, why would someone search specifically for posts with error tags?

Because they're funny as shit.