Post should not be tagged with 'pregnant' just because a character holds a pregancy test

It's my personal opinion that posts with characters holding a pregnancy test should not be tagged with pregnant unless they are also visibly pregnant with a protruding belly. If every character that holds a pregnancy test is tagged with pregnant then that would apply to nearly* 100% of the posts tagged with pregnancy_test.

Rationale:

• When searching for pregnant you are usually looking for characters with pregnant bellies.
• If you want both pregnant bellies and pregnancy implied by pregnancy tests then you can search for both pregnant and pregnancy_test separately. (Is there an OR-functionallity in the search? If so it could be done in a single search.)
• Searching for both pregnant and pregnancy_test should return results for characters with bellies AND holding pregnancy tests, whether it's a single character with both or multiple characters with either.
• The amount of art with pregnancy tests that are negative is negligible at best. So the tag overlap really is about 100%.

I've already enforced this on a few posts that I've come across. So I guess I'm also asking for input on whether I acted correctly along with trying to convince others to do as I do. Asking for forgiveness is easier than asking for permission, as they say. :>

*Exceptions would be images of pregnancy tests without characters that they belongs to, or characters holding a pregnancy test that shows negative.

Edit: Now afterwards I think the title of this forum post may have been misleading, so I changed it.

Agreed that pregnant should be used only for visibly pregnant characters. It looks like @arisboch is who added pregnant to these posts, so pinging him to this conversation.

If you want both pregnant bellies and pregnancy implied by pregnancy tests then you can search for both pregnant and pregnancy_test separately. (Is there an OR-functionallity in the search? If so it could be done in a single search.)

You can do an OR-search with ~pregnant ~pregnancy_test.

Luckily there's so far only 4 pages of results from searching for both pregnant and pregnancy_test. If this thread gets a mostly positive response then I will put on my gardening gloves and perform some tag pruning.

I'm also giving a +1 for using pregnant only on visibly pregnant characters.

Kapten-N said:

Luckily there's so far only 4 pages of results from searching for both pregnant and pregnancy_test. If this thread gets a mostly positive response then I will put on my gardening gloves and perform some tag pruning.

+1

Yeah, pregnant should only be used on pregnant characters. +1

I'm in agreement on having completely separate tags here. I do have one question, though. Are there images where a character is announcing she is pregnant (or it's otherwise implied she is pregnant) but without a pregnancy test visible? If we are sticking to a strict definition of only visible pregnancy for pregnant, then that situation (if it has come up) will need a new tag EDIT: Nevermind. There actually already is one: implied pregnancy. That has been used on one pregnancy test image, but I think it should be completely separate from it as well.

+1

+1 for a split between pregnant and implied pregnancy.

feline_lump said:

+1 for a split between pregnant and implied pregnancy.

I agree. This makes sense.

yes it should be reserved for visibility pregnant characters.

also a implied pregnancy tag will be useful tag for posts like #1969530 were there is no pregnancy tests being held.

Due to the positive feedback I'll go do some gardening now.

Edit: Gardening complete.