Danbooru

[bulk] Rose petal baths

Posted under Tags

I can't shake the feeling that rose_petal_bath is an exceptionally narrow tag that could be duplicated by a rose_petals ~bath ~bathing search. Seems like someone made an admirable effort to populate it, though.

By the way, yuzu_bath is a thing too. Maybe the bath wiki should link to these tags, to raise awareness of them?

kuuderes_shadow said:

Should the tag not be used for things like post #632222 then? No bath there.

One could argue that they're in a large bath, like in an onsen, and the rest of it is outside the image's frame.

iridescent_slime said:

One could argue that they're in a large bath, like in an onsen, and the rest of it is outside the image's frame.

Not visible in the image -> do not tag. And onsen does not implicate bath (and nor should it imo).

P.S. I'm fine with the currently proposed implication

iridescent_slime said:

I can't shake the feeling that rose_petal_bath is an exceptionally narrow tag that could be duplicated by a rose_petals ~bath ~bathing search. Seems like someone made an admirable effort to populate it, though.

I'm satisfied that the tag searches alone are sufficient. If I were still the requester I would reject. Nevertheless I propose just removing the rose_petal_bath tag were applied and tagging rose_petals, bath, or bathing were appropriate.

chinatsu said:

I'm satisfied that the tag searches alone are sufficient. If I were still the requester I would reject. Nevertheless I propose just removing the rose_petal_bath tag were applied and tagging rose_petals, bath, or bathing were appropriate.

I feel rose petal baths are significant enough to make their own category, but I just realized we also have the petals_on_water tag. (edit: sniped by Unbreakable)

Perhaps these two should be merged? It seems a lot of different people have used them so it's definitely not just a single user's effort, and even if petal baths might not be significant enough to deserve a tag by themselves, petals on water definitely are, as otherwise there'd be no way to find those posts.

1 2